2015 NFL Draft Winners and Losers

2015 NFL Draft Day One – Winners and Losers

The first day of the 2015 NFL Draft is in the books. Although the rumoured blockbuster trades for that coveted number two overall pick did not materialise, there were still a few surprises and plenty of excitement in Chicago. With six rounds still to be completed it is perhaps a little early for each team’s draft grades, however, here at The Neutral Zone we think we have spotted some clear winners and losers from the first round of action.

Round One Winners:

 

1. San Francisco 49ers

The ‘Niners moved down just two spots in the first round and were compensated with two additional draft picks, a fourth rounder this year and a fifth rounder next year. With rebuilding their defense the order of the day, Trent Baalke has to be pleased with his nights work, particularly after adding Arik Armstead – a giant of a man with even bigger potential.

Armstead prepares for the 2015 NFL DraftJim Tomsula will hope Armstead gives his ailing defense a lift

2. San Diego Chargers

There are usually clear winners and losers when a trade takes place, but in this case San Diego came out smelling of roses as well. Melvin Gordon could be the best running back in the draft and fills a huge Ryan Mathews shaped hole in the Chargers offense. Last year Gordon became the second all-time single season rusher in FBS history with 2,587 yards, running for 408 in one game alone! He could be the next LaDainian Tomlinson.

3. New England Patriots

When you are picking dead last the NFL Draft can be a difficult watch. Players slide off the board and the pickings get slimmer and slimmer. It will delight Bill Belichick therefore, that a player as highly regarded as Malcom Brown was still available so late in the proceedings. Projected to be selected as high as the top twenty in some mock drafts this was a steal from the reigning Super Bowl champions.

Brown was the last pick of the first round in the 2015 NFL DraftBrown was the last man off the board on Thursday night

4. New York Jets

Leonard Williams is widely considered to be the best overall player in the draft, bar none. That the star defensive end fell to the Jets at the sixth pick was one of the biggest surprises of the night. New York fans will be salivating at the thought of Williams lining up alongside Muhammad Wilkerson, Sheldon Richardson and Darrelle Revis in a defense that will surely strike fear into the hearts of the rest of the AFC East.

The best player in the 2015 NFL Draft fell the the JetsWilliams joins a fearsome front three

5. Pittsburgh Steelers

The Steelers have lost a lot of talent on defense in the weeks leading up to the 2015 NFL Draft. Troy Polamalu, Jason Worilds and Ike Taylor have all retired and yet more players have left in free agency, like cornerback Brice McCain. In selecting Bud Dupree with the 22nd pick Pittsburgh have begun to rebuild. After fellow edge rushers Shane Ray and Randy Gregory’s respective draft stocks plummeted due to drug allegations, Dupree seemed destined to be a top 15 pick. Pittsburgh will be thrilled that he was still on the board.

Bud Dupree slipped at the 2015 NFL DraftYou, Me and Dupree

 

 

Round One Losers

 

1. Washington

Iowa lineman Brandon Scherff was projected to be a solid first round pick, but selecting him fifth overall when Leonard Williams was still on the board seemed bizarre. Washington has significant defensive frailties and Williams was the best player on the board. Having traded away their 2013 and 2014 first round selections, maybe they were just rusty? Or perhaps they are trying to give beleaguered quarterback Robert Griffin III more protection in the hope that all those draft picks they gave up for him were not a waste.

Scherff was a surprise at the 2015 NFL DraftThere’s a new Scherff in town

2. Tennessee Titans

Marcus Mariota is one the very best quarterbacks to enter the draft in several years. In selecting the reigning Heisman trophy winner the Titans have seemingly played it by the book. They need a franchise QB and ex-Oregon Duck Mariota could fit the bill. However, there were rumours flying of gargantuan offers for the second overall pick. Philadelphia reportedly offered everything bar the Liberty Bell and still the Titans refused to do the deal. Tennessee have a roster that needs a complete rebuild and in keeping that coveted second pick they may have missed a chance to do so.

Mariota skipped the 2015 NFL Draft, but still had the jersey on hand.Super Mariota?

3. Denver Broncos

Denver traded two fifth round draft picks and Manny Ramirez to move up in the draft. A hefty price tag. Ramirez is headed back to the Detroit Lions (incidentally, the team who drafted him) and the Broncos have snapped up Shane Ray. There are question marks about Ray’s character after his run-in with the authorities over marijuana possession. Ironically, marijuana is legal in Colorado just not the NFL. Add to that a worrying injury to his toe and the Broncos have taken a rather expensive gamble.

A controversial selection at the 2015 NFL DraftThe Broncos were high on Ray

4. Indianapolis Colts

There was excitement in Indy as the Colts added speedy receiver Phillip Dorsett to an already explosive offense. With TY Hilton, Andre Johnson, Donte Moncrief and now Dorsett, Andrew Luck will be feeling pretty happy about the wide receivers in his stable. However, that doesn’t help them stop the run. The Colts were blown out in the AFC championship game by LeGarrette Blount who rushed for 148 yards and 3 touchdowns. Their leaky defensive line still doesn’t look any better. A missed opportunity.

A surprise pick at the 2015 NFL DraftWill Indianapolis want to make a U-turn?

5. Roger Goodell

The commissioner of the NFL had a tough draft. He was heckled consistently, each every time he entered the fray boos rang out, and looked uncomfortable all night long. Goodell’s popularity is seemingly at an all time low and even a bear hug and lift from Danny Shelton wouldn’t have lifted his spirits. The pressure clearly got to him as he mis-pronounced the second overall pick (not exactly an unknown or unexpected selection!) as Marcus ‘Mariato’. All in all it was hard to watch.

By Robin Held (@RobinHeldNFL)

Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone.

He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,