AFC SOUTH

The AFC South: The Worst Division in NFL history?

It was only last season that the Carolina Panthers were being heralded as the worst team to ever make the playoffs. They limped to a division title with a distinctly mediocre 7-8-1 record, sneaking past the 7-9 New Orleans Saints, thanks to their tie with the Cincinnati Bengals, in an NFC South bereft of any real quality. The 10-6 Philadelphia Eagles missed out on a postseason berth.

AFC SOUTHThe Panthers reached new heights in 2014

In 2010 the Seattle Seahawks went one better, finishing with a disappointing 7-9 record. It was good enough to sit stop the abject NFC West. Fast forward to the 2015 season and we are looking at the prospect of another playoff team boasting a losing record. This time, however, we could see our first ten loss team find its way into the wild card round…

The AFC South is on pace to become the worst division in NFL history. The New England Patriots and the Carolina Panthers remain unbeaten at 9-0, comfortably leading their respective divisions and looking to secure a first round bye. The Indianapolis Colts and the Houston Texans are also in prime playoff position, sharing a tie for the lead in the AFC South. The difference? They are both currently 4-5.

Screen Shot 2015-11-20 at 12.23.25

At first glance things do look pretty dire for the AFC South. However, upon closer inspection the true magnitude of its woes looms large. Here are the key factors in determining whether the 2015 AFC South really will become the worst division in NFL history:

1. Divisional Disparity

The AFC South currently lays claim to a combined 14 wins. For comparison, here are the win totals for the other seven divisions:

  • 23 – AFC East
  • 23 – NFC South
  • 19 – NFC North
  • 18 – AFC North
  • 18 – NFC West
  • 17 – AFC West
  • 15 – NFC East

The NFC East appears to provide the stiffest competition…!

Six of the AFC South’s 14 wins have been divisional match-ups. It seems the only teams that the AFC South are capable of beating are in the AFC South. There are, of course, another six in-division wins up for grabs in the second half of the season. The team that wins those crucial games stands the best chance of brandishing hats and t-shirts come January, whether it is as a six win outfit or not.

AFC SOUTHPainful for all involved

2. Quarterback Quagmire

The NFL is a passing league. It is therefore a quarterback driven league. The long-standing superpower of the AFC South, the Indianapolis Colts, currently boast 40-year-old Matt Hasselbeck as their starting quarterback. Franchise QB Andrew Luck’s injury trouble means the Colts are far less likely to pull off those unlikely upset victories, such as their thrilling takedown of the previously unbeaten Denver Broncos.

460xLosing Luck could take the wind out of Indy’s sails

The Houston Texans have gone one better at the quarterback position. They don’t know whether to start Brian Hoyer, TJ Yates or even Brandon Weeden, having already cut ties with Ryan Mallett. The Texans took down an unbeaten team of their own last week, handing the Cincinnati Bengals a 10-6 defeat. Unfortunately, despite TJ Yates’ ‘heroics’, the QB situation in Houston remains a mess, which is likely to translate to more losses in the forthcoming weeks.

The Tennessee Titans boast one of the up and coming stars of the game at quarterback, in Marcus Mariota. Mariota equalled the NFL record for most TD passes through his first three games with eight, matching Super Bowl winner Mark Rypien. On the downside, the Titans have one of the worst offensive lines in football. Mariota has already been sacked 24 times this season, and missed two games due to injury as a result. His offensive line has been unable to keep the rookie clean thus far.

AFC SOUTHMariota is sacked by Andre Branch

Jacksonville Jaguars QB Blake Bortles knows just how Mariota is feeling. He has hit the dirt 32 times this year, the second most in the league. He can shoulder some of the blame as well, as his 12 interceptions tie Andrew Luck and Matthew Stafford for second in the league, sitting just behind Peyton Manning who has tossed 17 passes into opposition hands.

AFC SOUTHIf not these three, is Yates the next man up?

If the AFC South cannot manage the quarterback position more effectively, adding to the win column seems pretty unlikely.

 

3. Defensive Disaster-zone

The AFC South boasts another dubious record. It is the only division in the league in which every team has conceded over 200 points:

 Team Points Allowed   NFL Rank
Jacksonville Jaguars  268  30th
 Tennessee Titans  233  22nd
 Indianapolis Colts  227  21st
Houston Texans  211 16th

The Texans appear to provide the sternest test for opposing offenses, boasting the 2014 ‘Defensive Player of the Year’ in J.J. Watt and former number one overall draft pick Jadeveon Clowney. Clowney has been plagued by injuries in his career to date, however, and has been fairly ineffective so far this season. The rest of the AFC South has not fared any better in trying to keep the opposition out of the endzone.

AFC SOUTH

If the AFC South continues to play soft on defense, expect many more points-fests in the closing stages of the year.

Despite all the talk of impending doom, is there reason to be cheerful in the AFC South? The short answer is yes. The 2010 Seattle Seahawks and the 2014 Carolina Panthers both entered the postseason with losing records and against the odds they both won their wild card match-up. If anything that proves that a losing record is not a death sentence for playoff football!

In all seriousness, there is hope for each and every one of the AFC South’s beleaguered members. The Jaguars pulled off a morale boosting come-from-behind win on Thursday night against the rival Titans. In a closely contested 19-13 win the Jags’ defense performed well, making game-changing plays late in the proceedings, and the offense provided just enough spark to get the job done. They moved to four wins and are back in contention. A late forced fumble gave Bortles great field position to throw the go-ahead TD and a game-sealing sack on the last play from scrimmage put the icing on the cake. It would also have been encouraging to see kicker Jason Myers making important field goals where earlier in the year he had failed emphatically.

AFC SOUTHMyers made all four of his field goal attempts

The Titans can also take heart from their defensive effort, and the play of Mariota has been promising of late. Of particular note was his his 23-yard dash for a score – the longest touchdown run by any quarterback this season. The Titans are still a franchise in transition as they move on from head coach Ken Whisenhunt’s tenure. If successor Mike Mularkey wants to hang on to his interim title, he might be better served showing more positivity in the play-calling. Mularkey settled for a 54-yard field goal attempt in the fourth quarter against the Jaguars when leading 13-6, which he later said he regretted.

AFC SOUTHMularkey needs to get the hang of this coaching malarkey

The Colts and the Texans share the division lead and are clearly in the race for a playoff berth, even if that race is moving at a snail’s pace. If Andrew Luck can return to form, as well as return from injury, sooner rather than later the Colts will have a legitimate chance to repeat last year’s run to the AFC Championship game.

The Texans will continue to lean on defensive stud J.J. Watt, as well as breakout star DeAndre Hopkins, who is having a career year at wide receiver. Hopkins ranks third in the NFL in receiving yards, fourth in touchdown catches, and first in targets, showing just how integral he has become to their struggling offense in the absence through injury of top running back Arian Foster. Hopkins’ performances have elevated his status into the ranks of the elite, with the likes of Julio Jones and Antonio Brown, as one of top receivers in the game.

deandre-hopkins-v-cincinnati_3377764Hopkins hauls in a crucial touchdown pass

It is not all doom and gloom then, for the AFC South. Although it would be a brave man to bet against yet another division champion entering the playoff picture boasting a losing record. Which of these struggling teams crawls to the top, though, remains to be seen.

By Robin Held (@RobinHeldNFL or @The_NeutralZone)

Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone. 

He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk

Tags: , , , , , , , ,
cammy

Coronating Cam

Some very good judges raised their eyebrows when the Carolina Panthers made Cam Newton one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL with a five-year, $103.8m extension in June. What the 26-year-old has done in the seven months since he signed the largest contract in franchise history has been nothing short