Brady gets ‘Rogered’ again…
Upon his appointment as the league commissioner Roger Goodell promised to clean up the integrity of the game. His mission to ‘protect the shield’ (a reference to the NFL’s logo) appears not to be working. In fact, instead of standing up for the all that is good in the NFL, Goodell has been swiftly disappearing down a rabbit hole of air pressure and smashed cellphones, alienating his allies in the process…
Patriots owner Robert Kraft, used to be one of Goodell’s staunchest supporters
Over the past six months, through an interminably drawn out series of independent investigations, disciplinary hearings and appeals, Goodell has stood firm in his convictions: Tom Brady, superstar quarterback, is banned for the first four games of the 2015 season.
But who does this really benefit?
Certainly not Brady. His reputation will be forever tarnished. Some are even going as far as to call into question his eligibility for the Hall of Fame. Brady’s suspicious destruction of his phone only adds fuel to the fire. He is going to continue to fight his suspension and try to clear his name, permitting the NFLPA to take the matter to court on his behalf. Even so, it is hard to see how Brady could have endured a worse pre-season as he prepares to defend the New England Patriots’ Super Bowl crown.
Another normal day in the Brady household
Does it benefit the league? On the face of it you might be tempted to say yes. Goodell’s decision puts a marker down; the NFL doesn’t tolerate cheating, no matter how marginal it may appear to the general public. In reality the benefits to the league appear less clear-cut. The 2015 season opener, a marquee event that showcases the reigning Super Bowl champions, is a far less appealing proposition without the Super Bowl MVP.
The rest of the AFC East will surely be pleased. They stand to gain a huge leg-up on the defending champions in Brady’s absence. But there will be some sections of those fan-bases that may feel an AFC East win this year would come with an asterisk. The 2008 Miami Dolphins are the only team other than New England to win the division since 2002. They did so against Matt Cassel as Brady went down with an ACL injury in game one. As Don Yee, Brady’s agent, said: “Goodell’s decision alters the competitive balance of the upcoming season.”
Chad Pennington’s Dolphins won the AFC East when Brady was missing. Was it a hollow victory?
Finally, and in some ways most importantly, does this help Goodell? You can’t help but feel that Roger has nailed his colours to the wrong mast. In a league rife with PED use, domestic violence and in some cases abject stupidity (firework safety seems to be a particular difficulty), surely Goodell should be making his stand against something other than deflated footballs.
Letroy Guion received a three game ban for this haul. Luckily he didn’t have a deflated ball in his car
Yes, the balls were slightly underinflated, and yes the destruction of Brady’s cellphone seems an all too convenient excuse. But when considering the fact that NFL players are role models, what would you rather clamp down on – drug use or air pressure? It seems like Goodell has targeted the wrong type of needle.
In truth ‘DeflateGate’ has been yet another high profile embarrassment for the league. It may not be long before the clamour to #FreeBrady leads to renewed calls to #FireGoodell. He survived the Ray Rice scandal, the Adrian Peterson scandal and the Greg Hardy scandal. But under intense media pressure and facing a continued volley of criticism from NFL fans across the globe, commissioner Roger Goodell may not be ‘protecting the shield’ for much longer, the shield may need to protect him.
By Robin Held (@RobinHeldNFL)
Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone.
He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk


