LAS VEGAS, NV - FEBRUARY 02:  A betting sheet for Super Bowl 50 between the Carolina Panthers and the Denver Broncos is displayed at the Race & Sports SuperBook at the Westgate Las Vegas Resort & Casino on February 2, 2016 in Las Vegas, Nevada. The newly renovated sports book, currently offering nearly 400 proposition bets for the Super Bowl, has the world's largest indoor LED video wall with 4,488 square feet of HD video screens measuring 240 feet wide and 20 feet tall.  (Photo Illustration by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

Dog Day Afternoon

Defense Wins Championships

We’ve heard it time and time again. A high-powered offense wins you games; a supersonic defense wins you titles. After the Denver Broncos dismantled the Carolina Panthers in Super Bowl 50, many were surprised – it was considered an upset. But should it have been? In recent years there is, in fact, a trend developing, one that illustrates the true value of defense when the stakes are at their highest. One that would suggest Denver should have been favourites all along.

The Broncos opened as 4-point underdogs with the Las Vegas SuperBook heading into the Super Bowl. That extended to as much as 6 points in the early betting. Carolina boasted the number one scoring offense in 2015 and was expected to move the ball at will, as they had done all season. That didn’t materialise. They scored a meagre ten points when all was said and done, over 21 points below their season average. Although few predicted the scale of Cam Newton and his offense’s capitulation, The warning signs were there.

Feb 7, 2016; Santa Clara, CA, USA; Denver Broncos outside linebacker DeMarcus Ware (94) grabs a loose ball ahead of Carolina Panthers quarterback Cam Newton (1) during the fourth quarter in Super Bowl 50 at Levi's Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Richard Mackson-USA TODAY SportsCam folded like a pack of cards

  • The fifth ranked scoring offense of 2015, that of Ben Roethlisberger and the Pittsburgh Steelers, scored just 16 points against Denver in the divisional round, a full ten below their season average.
  • The third ranked scoring offense of 2015, belonging to the New England Patriots, who boasted the greatest playoff quarterback in NFL history in Tom Brady, put up just 18 points in a losing effort in the AFC Championship game – 11 points under their season average.

Yes, there were mitigating factors here. All-pro receiver Antonio Brown, star running back LeVeon Bell and Bell’s backup, DeAngelo Williams, were missing through injury for Pittsburgh. The Patriots had their own injury woes – their offensive line was held together with duct tape by that late stage of the season. However, Denver could only beat who was put in front of them. And they did so, on the back of two excellent defensive displays.

So why wasn’t such a dominant defense being valued? Was this a one off? Let’s take a look at the previous five Super Bowls, noting defensive rankings, pre-game odds and the winner of the MVP award:

Super Bowl 50 – Denver Broncos 24 – 10 Carolina Panthers

vonnyBeware: Miller’s Crossing 

As four-point underdogs Von Miller, Derek Wolfe, Malik Jackson and DeMarcus Ware ran riot against the Panthers’ beleaguered offense. Carolina turned the ball over again and again in the face of the NFL’s number one ranked defense and Miller picked up MVP honours. He was a rank outsider to secure the award, opening at 60-1.

Underdog wins. Defensive MVP

 

Super Bowl XLIX – New England Patriots 28 – 24 Seattle Seahawks

butlerNo tears of joy for punters

The dominant Seahawks defense, marshalled by talismanic cornerback Richard Sherman, was a force to be reckoned with. They entered the game ranked first in the league and as defending champions the Seahawks were installed as one-point favourites. New England managed to overcome that Seahawks defense thanks to a ten-point fourth quarter comeback led by three-time Super Bowl MVP Tom Brady. Nevertheless, it came down to a defensive play for the ages by unheralded rookie Malcolm Butler to seal the win. The Patriots defense was clearly no slouch, ranked 8th in the league that year.

Underdog wins. QB MVP

 

Super Bowl XLVIII – Seattle Seahawks 43 – 8 Denver Broncos

gaminghDefense pays

This was a true battle of offense and defense. Peyton Manning and the record setting Broncos offense had steamrolled the league in 2013, setting new NFL records for touchdowns and points scored in a single season. They were favoured to lift the Lombardi by 2.5 points. The Seahawks defense led the league in points allowed, yards allowed and takeaways, the first team to lead all three categories since the 1985 Chicago Bears. The end result was just as emphatic as in 1985. Malcolm Smith earned MVP honours at linebacker, becoming just the third linebacker to do so. No bookmaker even set individual odds on Smith winning the MVP. He was part of the “field” wager, which paid 20/1 in most places.

Underdog wins. Defensive MVP

  

Super Bowl XLVII – Baltimore Ravens 34 – 31 San Francisco 49ers

defenseyKap sacked not stacked

The 49ers were 4.5 point favourites, with dual threat QB Colin Kaepernick threatening to dismantle the Baltimore D. The Ravens were rated as the 12th best defense in the league that year, but laid claim to the third ranked defense for four consecutive seasons prior to 2012. This was a strong unit, regardless of recent form. Sure enough, Ray Lewis and the gang held firm on a goal line stand as time expired, securing an upset victory. Notably, the 49ers actually boasted the 2nd ranked defense in the league that season, but Ravens QB Joe Flacco played a magnificent, MVP calibre game. Still, this was an upset however you look at it.

Underdog wins. QB MVP

 

Super Bowl XLVI – New York Giants 21 – 17 New England Patriots

tuckTuck rules

The New England Patriots came into the game with the NFL’s third ranked scoring offense. They were expected to beat the Giants and their 27th ranked defense and were favoured by 2.5 points. The Patriots, however, had the league’s 31st ranked defense. They simply could not stop the MVP, Eli Manning, in the fourth quarter with the game on the line. Remarkably, the Patriots gave in and allowed the go-ahead TD, in order to try and get the ball back in Brady’s hands with some time left on the clock. It didn’t work. Another Giants defense had put the brakes on Brady and the Patriots, harking back to the 2007 season where Big Blue spoiled a perfect season. The Patriots scored 15 fewer points than their season average.

Underdog wins. QB MVP

 

So where does this leave us? An incredible five out of five previous Super Bowl winners have been classed as underdogs by Las Vegas. The team who has the highest ranked defense has won three of five. Two of the previous three MVPs have been linebackers. It’s clear to see that odds makers are often forced info undervaluing defense. The betting public backs these offensive teams so aggressively they become big favourites.  The American betting public is not particularly good at picking Super Bowl winners!

The advice for punters when Super Bowl LI rolls around?

  • Bet against whomever the bookmakers install as favourites to lift the Lombardi in Texas.
  • Value the team that has the higher ranked defense.
  • Back the underdog’s quarterback to win MVP – 54% of all Super Bowl MVPs have been quarterbacks.
  • Failing that, back their standout defensive player.