Did Dez Bryant Catch It?
It’s the divisional round of the NFL play-offs. The Lombardi trophy is gleaming through the fog, only inches away. Tony Romo can almost taste that shiny metal on his lips. It’s fourth and two; instead of running the ball Romo lets it fly to his star receiver Dez Bryant. It seems like fate. Bryant leaps into the air, secures the ball in his left hand. It’s the perfect Cowboys moment. Another Dez Bryant catch for the ages. America’s team does it again. Dallas collectively cries out in pure ecstasy, orgies commence, babies are conceived, until…
Who has two thumbs and likes making Cowboys cry?
PEEEEEEEEP! (that’s a referee’s whistle FYI) IT’S THE PERFECT TIME FOR ANOTHER CLASSIC GENE STERATORE BOTCHED REFEREEING DECISION! Cue Benny Hill theme!
So, let’s review the facts. To complete a catch in the NFL, you have to control the ball and maintain possession throughout the whole process of the catch. Bryant does appear to control the ball in his right hand and then take one step towards the endzone, his right arm then hits the ground first before he goes down completely. The ground then knocks the ball out of his hand before he safely corrals it. Normally this would count as his second step, a telltale sign of a complete catch, which happens well before the ball hits the ground, and before the ball is knocked loose. But to be fair to poor old Steratore, it’s pretty unclear really. This call could have gone either way. So in that case shouldn’t the ruling on the field stand? I’m not a ref so I might be way off. Who knows? Apparently not even the refs!
Time to let Dez Bryant catch his breath.
What made this the most controversial call in recent history was not really about the call itself, but more about how damn unsure the refs seemed about it. It was like they took a few looks at the replay and couldn’t really decide so Steratore just flipped a mental coin and went with incomplete, ending the Cowboys’ hopes of winning the Lombardi. This is one in a long stream of instances showing how ridiculous refereeing has become in the NFL. Here’s what Steratore had to say about the Dez Bryant catch:
“Although the receiver is possessing the football, he must maintain possession of that football throughout the entire process of the catch,” Steratore said. “In our judgement he maintained possession but continued to fall and never had another act common to the game. We deemed that by our judgement to be the full process of the catch, and at the time he lands and the ball hits the ground, it comes loose as it hits the ground, which would make that incomplete; although he re-possesses it, it does contact the ground when he reaches so the repossession is irrelevant because it was ruled an incomplete pass when we had the ball hit the ground.”
Concise. So easy a layman could understand it. How could anyone be left in doubt? At this rate it won’t be long before we see even more ridiculous referees’ explanations creeping into the game:
Upon further review, the receiver did not complete the process of the catch, while counting backwards from ten, maintaining eye contact with the official at all times.
Upon further review, we don’t actually know what a catch is – we just throw the pretty flags in the air when Mr Goodell tells us to.
Upon further review, my flies are undone.
It’s a shame to have a play-off game decided by some haphazard referee calls. You hate to see it. You really do. Poor Dez.
The Jambo Zone By James Bristow (@JamesMBristow)




