Trading Places – Winners and Losers of Free Agency
Im starting to feel like @nfl addict!! More trades, signings, or rumors please!! Now!! Refresh, update, and scroll!!
— Andrew Whitworth (@BigWhit77_fndn) March 10, 2015
Free agency has officially begun! And nobody is safe. Cincinnati Bengals offensive tackle Andrew Whitworth summed up the atmosphere perfectly with his tweet – everyone was enjoying the intoxicating ride last night. Yes, free agents have been making moves for nearly a week now, with big names like Ndamukong Suh and Randall Cobb making even bigger decisions, but the real fun started yesterday evening.
At 20:00 GMT the fireworks began. As the league’s trade window opened, a flurry of trades set social media alight and household names swapped franchises at a breakneck speed that the NFL has never before experienced. Everybody was excited, fans and players alike. Even Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay got carried away:
Let the games begin!!!! Building that MONSTER!!!!!!!!!
— Jim Irsay (@JimIrsay) March 10, 2015
It wasn’t just trades that shocked pigskin fans either. Tennessee Titans quarterback Jake Locker added to the chaos, announcing his shock retirement at the age of 26. Pittsburgh Steelers linebacker Jason Worilds, swiftly followed suit, at the ripe old age of 27. The fact that Worilds was a free agent in line for a payday made his decision even more surprising.
After the dust settled on a manic first day of wheeling and dealing, which teams came out on top and who made moves they might regret? We choose our three winners and losers below:
Winners:
1. Seattle Seahawks
The two-time defending NFC champions are in no mood to relinquish their crown, it appears. After securing the services of Marshawn Lynch for another two years, Pete Carroll’s boys sent shock-waves though Louisiana by landing former New Orleans Saints tight end Jimmy Graham. He is quite literally a huge addition and is sure to improve a relatively weak receiving corps. Over the past four seasons, Jimmy Graham has hauled in 50 red-zone receptions – that is the same as all of the Seahawks’ tight ends over the past eight years combined. A jump ball to Graham in goal-to-go situations is definitely a better option than a slant to Ricardo Lockette!
The Seahawks grabbed Graham, who wasn’t even a free agent.
2. Philadelphia Eagles
Perhaps a controversial choice, and many would argue they are in fact one of the biggest losers so far, but Chip Kelly seems to have a plan. Having let 1,000 yard rusher LeSean McCoy and 1,000 yard receiver Jeremy Maclin leave town, he has now traded away starting quarterback Nick Foles. It seems drastic, but Kelly could be lining up his chips for a big move in the draft.
Sam Bradford for Nick Foles? Chip Kelly I understand there's a Method to your Madness but the Madness to your Method is questionable! #Truth
— Deion Sanders (@DeionSanders) March 10, 2015
Sam Bradford, a former number one overall pick, plus a second rounder is decent compensation for Foles. That combination could be enticing trade bait for the Tennessee Titans, perhaps persuading them to allow the Eagles to draft Kelly’s Oregon protégé Marcus Mariota second overall. Even if there is no trade to be had, Foles was by no means a sure thing in the NFL and Bradford was incredibly accurate in college. Accuracy is something Kelly craves in his offense, second only to speed.
3. The AFC East (well, 3/4 of it!)
In the most lopsided division in football, perhaps parity is about to be restored. The Bills, Dolphins and Jets had to endure yet another Brady and Belichick Super Bowl win last year; they are doing their level best to ensure it doesn’t happen again this season. The Bills have grabbed LeSean McCoy to give Rex Ryan his ground and pound offense. The Dolphins landed the big fish in Ndamukong Suh and are hoping he can rejuvenate a leaky defensive line. But the team that has made the biggest moves is the New York Jets. Not only did they sign a top wide receiver in Brandon Marshall, but they added two of the better free agent cornerbacks on the market. Buster Skrine is a strong addition to a weak unit, but the acquisition of the New England Patriots very own Darrelle Revis, one of the league’s best ever defensive backs, was the biggest story of the day. The race for the AFC East is hotting up.
Still, with exorbitant money being paid to the likes of Suh and Revis, don’t count out Belichick, the master of the salary cap, just yet…
Very interesting first 1/2 hour of NFL free agency. A lot of these deals are about money which isn't always best way to build a team
— Tony Dungy (@TonyDungy) March 10, 2015
Losers:
1. San Francisco 49ers
Since the departure of head coach Jim Harbaugh, things have gone from bad to worse for the 49ers. They have to be considered the biggest losers of free agency so far. Here is who they have parted ways with already:
RB Frank Gore – Signed with the Indianapolis Colts
G Mike Iupati – Signed with the Arizona Cardinals
LB Patrick Willis – Retired
DE Justin Smith – Retired
Smith, Gore, Willis and Iupati have combined to play 30 seasons for the 49ers and earn 20 Pro Bowl berths with the team. All four could merit Hall-of-Fame consideration by the time their respective careers are over. A huge blow.
Frank Gore inadvertently sums up the mood in San Francisco
To make matters worse, the 49ers appeared to panic and overspend on Baltimore Ravens wide receiver Torrey Smith. $40 million over five years seems like a lot of money for Smith. Particularly as he had a career-low 49 receptions and dropped 11 passes last season, which tied for second-most in the NFL.
2. Jacksonville Jaguars
As free agency began the Jaguars reportedly had $66.8 million in available salary cap space. They should have made a big impact on the free agency market. However, Denver Broncos tight end Julius Thomas is their only big signing of the period so far. Thomas has been a consistent threat in Peyton Manning’s offense, making the last two Pro Bowls and catching 24 touchdowns in the process. Blake Bortles is no Peyton Manning though, and the Jaguars will not have the luxury of players like Demaryius Thomas to draw defenses’ attention away from Julius. Beware the Eric Decker effect.
Julius Thomas will give Jaxson de Ville a run for his money in the style stakes.
3. New Orleans Saints
Last but by no means least are the New Orleans Saints. The Saints have declared open season on their roster. Star tight end Jimmy Graham is now a Seahawk. They also released veteran linebacker and captain Curtis Lofton and longtime running back Pierre Thomas. With more big moves still possible, it is a nervous time for Saints fans. Rumours are even beginning to swirl about quarterback Drew Brees. Meanwhile, top cornerback Keenan Lewis voiced his displeasure over the Saints’ unwillingness to guarantee the final three years of his contract – insisting that they trade or release him if they are not willing to commit to him. It looks like there are rough times ahead in Louisiana.
Saints GM Loomis on Jimmy Graham trade: It was time to “make a bold move” to help the defense http://t.co/jW4LtAkQJh
— Around The NFL (@AroundTheNFL) March 11, 2015
Nevertheless, Sean Payton and his Saints could have chosen to try and patch up their struggling roster and somehow sneak into the playoffs in a weak division. That is not how Payton likes to do things. Remember, this is a man who called an onside kick to start the second half in the Super Bowl. It remains to be seen whether this latest gamble will pay off.
By Robin Held (@RobinHeldNFL)
Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone.
He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk


