MVP, Raiders and Rivers

3 and Out: MVP, Raiders and Rivers

3 and out: Three of the hottest topics in the NFL are up for debate. Tweet us your opinion at @the_neutralzone

1st Down: Will a defensive player ever be crowned MVP again?

If the NFL’s MVP trophy does not end up sitting proudly above J.J. Watt’s Houston fireplace at the end of the season, the league might as well change the name of the award to the most valuable quarterback/running back.

The 6ft 5inch Houston Texans defensive end is the complete football player, compiling the complete season. The numbers should make you giddy.

  • 54 tackles
  • 11.5 sacks
  • 3 forced fumbles
  • 5 recovered fumbles
  • An interception return touchdown
  • A fumble recovery touchdown
  • 3 receiving touchdowns (5 touchdowns in total)

JJ Watt should be MVPTurn down for Watt? Surely J.J. won’t be turned down for the MVP award…

No defensive player has destroyed offensive lines with such ease and on such regularity since the great Reggie White donned a Philadelphia Eagles uniform. Watt is one-man wrecking ball. His speed, technique, leadership, work-rate and sheer productivity are unmatched.

Add to that, his amazing ability to catch touchdowns from the tight-end position and you have a man playing a totally different sport to all of his contemporaries.

Despite these facts, Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers is the overwhelming favourite to be named league MVP. Nobody can deny Rodgers’ brilliance and his own numbers this season are sensational. He has 32 touchdown passes, only three interceptions and a passer rating of 118.6. He is as clinical and accurate as a heart surgeon and would be a worthy winner any other year.

I don’t think the Texans frustrating 6-6 season should count against Watt when discussing individual awards. The 25-year-old has been super-human this season and truly deserves to be the latest defensive player, and the first since New York Giants linebacker Lawrence Taylor in 1986, to be named MVP.

A similar debate is raging in Europe over the worthy recipient of the Ballon d’Or, the award given to the round ball’s best player. Germany’s World Cup winning goalkeeper Manuel Neuer, like Watt, is a once in a generation sportsman who has redefined his position during an astonishing year. Despite some fierce lobbying from the German media, Cristiano Ronaldo is seen as a shoe-in to walk away with the accolade.

Neuer should be football's MVPRonaldo, Messi, Messi, Messi, Messi, Ronaldo – Neuer?

If 2014 isn’t Watt’s year, we will almost certainly never see another defensive player as league MVP.

2nd Down: Is Jim Harbaugh the answer to Oakland’s woes?

The 1-11 Oakland Raiders are an embarrassment to themselves, their city and the whole league. With Jim Harbaugh and the San Francisco 49ers seemingly set for divorce, there is talk that Harbaugh will stay in the bay area and take on the Oakland head coaching job.

Harbaugh thinks he is the MVPOakland might try to grab Harbaugh

The Niners are reportedly angling for a trade. This would be a real mistake for the Raiders. Their whole roster needs strengthening – wasting draft picks on a cantankerous head coach who appears to have lost the support of his players and superiors after one disappointing season would be madness.

Harbaugh may be a victim of his own initial success in San Francisco. The 49ers over achieved in his first few years and he is now paying the price for the inevitable drop off. I would still leave him well alone.

Oakland should have all the chips come draft day. With the number one pick more than likely theirs, they have the opportunity to trade it away and actually build a team around pocket passer Derek Carr. Every draft pick is going to be vital to this toiling organisation – trading any pick away for a coach, no matter how much they admire Harbaugh, would be lunacy.

Could Carr be a future MVPTrading for Harbaugh could see Carr crash in Oakland.

3rd Down: Just what is it about Philip Rivers and this time of the year?

The San Diego Chargers quarterback comes alive in the last few weeks of the regular season. Philip Rivers has the best record of any QB since 1970 in the final four games the season with 29 wins and only 3 losses. The second man on the list is a certain Tom Brady, with 40 wins and only 8 defeats. Brady brings his New England Patriots to Southern California on Sunday Night to face Rivers and his Chargers in what promises to be another late night cracker.

Brady has already won the MVPBrady and Rodgers are year-long MVPs, but Rivers is top in December.

New England, smarting from their narrow defeat to Green Bay last Sunday, rarely lose two on the bounce; Rivers rarely loses in December.

UK viewers should try and get a Sunday lunchtime nap in, because the late game is must watch television.

This stretch of the Patriots schedule always looked hazardous, but they cannot afford a loss if they want to secure the number one seed in the AFC and avoid a post-season trip to Denver.

San Diego are buoyant after a last-gasp win in Baltimore last week. But their run-in is even more brutal with Denver next up, after New England. That game is followed by trips to San Francisco and Kansas City. A run of games that will really put Philip Rivers’ ‘Mr December’ title to the test.

Philip Rivers is Mr DecemberRivers is on a run in December

By Sean Held

 

Tags: , , , , ,