Packers Pay Preseason Price
The preseason excites fans. For six long months, following the intoxicating climax of the Super Bowl, there is no pro football whatsoever. For some teams, such as the oh-so-close Seattle Seahawks, that hiatus must have felt even longer. For the 20 teams to miss out on playoff football entirely, it is purgatory.
When the enforced hibernation finally ends, and the 24-7 cycle of NFL news stories moves away from ‘DeflateGate’ and back towards touchdowns and turnovers, it is understandably refreshing. But when you take a closer look, and forget about the legion of football-starved fanatics, are these preseason games really worth playing, let alone watching?
Unlike the Detroit Lions D, RG3 didn’t enjoy his preseason outing much
Last night the Green Bay Packers number one wide receiver, Jordy Nelson, left a preseason game against the Pittsburgh Steelers with a suspected anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear. He also left with two receptions for 24 yards. Which is more important? The loss of Nelson is a devastating blow for a franchise that was one bobbled onside kick away from reaching the Super Bowl last season and looked certainties for a deep playoff run again this year. Nelson, unfortunately, is not the only first team star to suffer a year-ending injury in a preseason game in 2015. To name but a few:
Maurkice Pouncey – Steelers C – Broken Left Ankle
Niles Paul – Washington TE – Broken Left Ankle
Logan Paulsen – Washington TE – Toe Injury
Bennett Jackson – Giants S – Torn ACL
Phil Loadholt – Vikings OT – Torn Achilles
Jarius Wynn – Bills DL – ACL Injury
Shaun Suisham – Steelers K – Torn ACL
Pouncey’s injury capped off an ugly preseason game for both teams
Of course this list only includes some of the brutal, season-ending injuries sustained so far. Countless others have been carted off the field and are likely to miss regular season action. Even more sobering a thought is that we are only halfway through this seemingly punishing schedule of four preseason games. No wonder star players are unwilling to take snaps when there is nothing to gain and everything to lose.
Andrew Luck took no chances, leaving his first preseason game mid-drive!
With so many injuries occurring and first team players seeing so little action, you have to wonder why we even have preseason games in the first place? Any NFL head coach or general manager will tell you that they are absolutely vital for developing and evaluating young players. When training camp rosters must be cut down from 90 to 53 players you need as many opportunities to test your squad as you can muster. I doubt, however, that anyone in Wisconsin was worried about whether Nelson would make the cut or not. So why was he playing at all? His quarterback, 2014 NFL MVP Aaron Rodgers, was equally mystified:
“It’s difficult to lose a guy over a meaningless game. It’s disappointing that you have injuries like this one in the preseason.”
Without suiting up for a pointless clash in the preseason, the rigours of the preseason, with OTAs and then training camp, are tough enough to get through unscathed. Just ask Kelvin Benjamin. The Carolina Panthers stud wideout went down with a torn ACL without even making contact with another player. He is not alone either. The Jacksonville Jaguars’ first round pick Dante Fowler Jr. tore his ACL on day one as a pro. The Chicago Bears’ seventh overall pick Kevin White has undergone surgery for a shin injury and could miss most of the year. The list goes on…
Foul luck for the embattled Jaguars franchise
Despite the heart-wrenching injuries to beloved franchise players and exciting new prospects alike, the preseason does have its upside for the fans. The games throw up interesting narratives and despite a total absence of star power in the second half, they build anticipation for the coming season. It would be a hard-hearted fan, for example, that doesn’t find themselves rooting for Jarryd Hayne. The Australian rugby league player-turned San Francisco 49ers return man has shone in the preseason, returning kicks with aplomb and taking snaps at running back for good measure. The mad genius Chip Kelly and his Philadelphia Eagles have also thrilled the crowds, scoring a whopping 76 points in two games with a mix of special teams thunder, spread offense trickery and above all, Tebow time. There is clearly still some allure left in these preseason games, but whether we need four is another matter.
Superstar golfer Rory McIlroy recently tore his ankle ligaments kicking a football around with his mates. His seemingly pointless injury left him unable to defend his title at The Open. McIlroy and his army of supporters were clearly disappointed, but more importantly the sport seemed to have lost out. Despite the obvious joy the return of the NFL signals to millions of fans across the world and the cash it makes the league’s 32 owners, it has always been, and always will be, tempered by the futility of preseason injuries. When Jordy Nelson lay stricken on the ground last night, every fan knew the NFL would be worse off without him in 2015.
By Robin Held (@RobinHeldNFL)
Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone.
He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk


