AFC South Preview & Power Rankings
Dylan Baker previews the 2015/2016 NFL campaign and shares his pre-season rankings. Up next is the AFC South – can anyone dethrone Andrew Luck and the Indianapolis Colts?
AFC South
Indianapolis Colts
Since its inception in 2002, the AFC South has been a division dominated by the Indianapolis Colts. With Peyton Manning and subsequently Andrew Luck leading the charge, the Colts have won the title nine times out of a possible 13 – and there is no reason to suggest they won’t top the table again in 2015. The biggest reason for their dominance is that they have been the only team in the division with a bona fide star at the most important position. Although it’s too early to anoint Luck the next all-time great quarterback, the fourth-year starter is a sublime talent despite the odd flaw in the mechanics and heads into 2015 with the weapons around him to have a historically good season.
Andrew Luck has emulated Peyton Manning, bringing the Colts continued success in the AFC South
By signing veteran Frank Gore in free agency, Indianapolis finally have a decent running back for the first time in recent memory, and the first-round draft selection of the blisteringly quick Phillip Dorsett adds yet more depth to a stacked receiving corps. Gore is no spring chicken but, even at 31, is the perfect fit for the Colts – a model of consistency who can be relied on to perform week in, week out and, crucially, take some weight off Luck’s shoulders. Dan ‘Boom’ Herron last year showed his worth as a useful back-up – recording 351 yards at an average of 4.5 per carry – and can now be used sparingly to keep Gore fresh.
In my pre-draft wide-receiver list, I ranked Dorsett very highly and wasn’t surprised to see the Miami alum taken in the first round – but the Colts calling his number was a surprise. Adding another speedy receiver to the most potent passing attack in the NFL last season seemed a touch indulgent – especially after the acquisition of Andre Johnson in free agency. The former Houston Texan is perhaps no longer the force that he was, but last year still managed to haul in 936 yards as a number-two receiver for a team without an established quarterback.
The Colts new look wide receiver corps works out at organised team activities
Addressing the offensive line, to make life easier for Gore and Luck, seemed the priority in the draft. Or strengthening the defensive side of the ball: last season, the Colts’ line allowed 4.3 yards per carry on the ground and the secondary gave up 7.2 yards per attempt through the air – ranking them 23rd and 16th in the NFL respectively. The front office did tick the boxes from the second round onwards, however – taking defensive linemen Henry Anderson and David Parry, cornerback D’Joun Smith and safety Clayton Geathers. For a team gearing up for a Super Bowl run, the concern is whether any of this quartet represent an immediate upgrade on last year’s starters.
Even discounting divisional games against the unfancied Jaguars and Titans, the schedule appears reasonably kind to Indianapolis. The Buccaneers, Saints, Jets and Broncos are all teams they will be confident of beating at Lucas Oil Stadium. The Colts also host the Patriots – a match-up to savour that will pit Luck against Tom Brady on his scheduled return from suspension. Buffalo, Carolina, Atlanta, Pittsburgh and Miami on the road won’t be pushovers but will equally hold no fear for Indianapolis.
So, overall, it’s a positive outlook for the Colts – hot favourites for yet another division title and a genuine Super Bowl contender. Until the Texans can make a game of it by solving their quarterback puzzle, expect it to be business as usual in the South and another 11-plus-win season for Chuck Pagano’s men. Then, it’s just those pesky playoffs (and again, possibly the Patriots) to deal with…
The Colts have found playoff football, and in particular consistency, difficult under Andrew Luck
Divisional ranking: 1st
Houston Texans
As fun as the Houston Texans should be to watch on the next series of HBO’s Hard Knocks, I am more intrigued by how they will perform when the real action begins.
The position under the most scrutiny is, of course, quarterback, where the untested Ryan Mallett will compete with former New England team-mate Brian Hoyer and second-year signal-caller Tom Savage to lead an otherwise strong-looking Texans team.
The quarterback competition is hotting up in Houston
The more experienced Hoyer is favourite to start the campaign under center but, after a season with Cleveland that started promisingly and ended ugly, his name at the top of the depth chart won’t inspire much optimism in Houston.
Mallett’s sample size for the Texans – or in the NFL, for that matter – is small, so deeming him a viable number one seems presumptuous. He played just one full game last season, completing 20 of 30 passes for 211 yards, two touchdowns and an interception. Savage, signed as a project in the fourth round of the 2014 draft, also started a single game, completing ten of 19 passes for 127 yards and an interception in a week 15 loss to the Colts. Not the most encouraging numbers.
The good news for Texans fans is that whoever takes the snaps in week one won’t necessarily be relied on to carry the offense, merely limit the mistakes and lean on an effective running game led by four-time Pro Bowler Arian Foster. In 2014, Foster chalked up 1,246 yards (the sixth-most of any running back), with an average of 4.8 per carry – higher than DeMarco Murray, Eddie Lacy and Marshawn Lynch. He did this behind an offensive line that performed well in the run game – far better than in pass protection.
Texans fans will be grateful they have Arian Foster to lean on
Foster cannot do it all by himself, however, and the 28-year-old has not been without injury problems, so the Texans need to find a way of increasing the impact of their much-maligned tight-end group, led by the underwhelming Garrett Graham. Graham has accumulated just 96 receptions for 1,029 yards over four seasons in Houston.
They will also have to find a way of replacing the production of veteran wide-out Andre Johnson, who jumped ship to division rivals Indianapolis. At 6’2” and 217lb, Jaelen Strong will be expected to fill the void. The rookie, picked up after slipping to the third round of this year’s draft, has all the hallmarks of a powerful receiver who will thrive on contested balls. However, he must improve his route-running and ability to create separation – especially as the quarterback feeding him is likely to be less than perfect in terms of accuracy.
Strong will dovetail the main aerial threat, DeAndre Hopkins. According to Pro Football Focus, Hopkins has had the best hands of any wide receiver over the past three years, snagging 97 per cent of all catchable passes thrown his way. In 2014, he recorded 1,210 yards at an extremely impressive 15.9 per reception – the second-highest average of any player with 100-plus targets, behind the Colts’ TY Hilton.
Hopkins is an underrated pass catching threat
On the defensive side, one name stands out above all others: the man many believe should have been recognised as the league MVP for 2014 and the consensus ‘most terrifying player in football’ – JJ Watt. NFL writers have run out of superlatives to describe just how good the 26-year-old is. Statistically, Watt is unparalleled, totalling more combined hits and sacks in 2014 than Sheldon Richardson, Muhammad Wilkerson, Calais Campbell and Fletcher Cox achieved between them. Not satisfied with that, he also lined up as a tight end on a handful of goal-line plays, catching all three passes thrown his way for a trio of touchdowns.
Elsewhere on the line, the addition of decorated nose tackle Vince Wilfork will solidify the middle and help an impressive and aggressive run defense get even tougher this year. The linebacker corps got a shot in the arm in the shape of 6’4”, 250lb second-round draft selection Benardrick McKinney. The Texans coaching staff love the size, speed, versatility and leadership skills of McKinney, one of the pre-eminent linebackers in Mississippi State history. Alongside him should be last year’s first overall draft pick Jadeveon Clowney, who reports suggest is rehabbing well after undergoing surgery on his knee. Whether Clowney, whose game relies heavily on explosive bursts, will ever be able to live up to the potential he showed at South Carolina remains to be seen, but getting him back fit is a step in the right direction.
Wilfork will stiffen the defensive front. But is he also the answer at quarterback?
The Texans have plugged some holes in their porous secondary this off-season. First, in free agency with the addition of former Denver safety Rahim Moore and then in the draft through first-round draft pick Kevin Johnson – an imposing physical specimen who will improve the team at cornerback alongside the serviceable Kareem Jackson and Johnathan Joseph.
Facing a schedule that outside of their division looks pretty favourable – with home games against the Chiefs, Buccaneers, Jets, Patriots and Saints, plus road trips to the Panthers, Falcons, Dolphins, Bengals and Bills – Houston should finish second in the AFC South comfortably, with an outside shot at the play-offs. If only the Texans had a franchise quarterback. Perhaps they should ask Watt to step up to the plate in 2015, he does everything else!
Divisional ranking: 2nd
Jacksonville Jaguars
You have to feel sorry for the Jacksonville Jaguars. Who knows how many mirrors the franchise has broken since its inception in 1995 for their first-round draft selections to routinely end in disaster. Their latest victim is this year’s number-three overall pick Dante Fowler Jr, who was just minutes into his first mini-camp practice when he tore his left anterior cruciate ligament. It’s a crushing blow to the player, who will miss the entire 2015/16 season, but also his employers, who saw him as potentially the centrepiece of their defense for years to come.
Another first round pick bites the dust in Jacksonville
That Jacksonville finished last season with the sixth-most sacks in the NFL and have proven performers on the front line (most notably Jared Odrick) suggest they can absorb the blow of losing Fowler for the year. However, the Jaguars gave up 2,033 yards on the ground last year (the fifth-most in the NFL) and were, despite their sack total, not much better though the air – allowing 7.7 yards per pass attempt (the seventh-worst of any team).
Jacksonville moved in free agency to sign Odrick, a defensive tackle who is coming off an excellent season in Miami and should pressurise opposition quarterbacks. And while newly acquired defensive end Chris Clemons is not getting any younger, he recorded eight sacks and forced four fumbles with the Seahawks last term. The addition of former San Francisco linebacker Dan Skuta also appears a shrewd move, while cornerback Davon House and safety Sergio Brown improve the secondary following their arrival from Green Bay and Indianapolis respectively.
In 2014, the weakest link of a weak team was undoubtedly the offensive line. Jacksonville gave up a monumental 71 sacks – 13 more than the second-biggest culprit, Washington. To its credit, the front office has at least tried to rectify the problem this off-season, signing ex-Cowboy Jermey Parnell at right tackle and third-round draft pick AJ Cann, who should push 2012 Pro Bowler Zane Beadles for a starting spot at guard. After a difficult rookie campaign, center Luke Bowanko now has competition from former Raider Stefan Wisniewski.
Bortles is sacked again – a depressingly familiar sight for Jags fans
Expect new offensive co-ordinator Greg Olsen to place a greater emphasis on the running game in order to protect quarterback Blake Bortles more effectively than the offensive line managed in his rookie year. Not that Toby Gerhart’s performances last season gave Olsen good reason to do so. The former back-up for Adrian Peterson in Minnesota was only able to rush for 326 yards and two touchdowns; while his replacement, Denard Robinson, fared little better. But there is renewed hope in the form of second-round draft pick TJ Yeldon, who enters the pro ranks after an impressive college career at Alabama.
When Bortles does look to throw, his first port of call need no longer be a fledgling flock of receivers but the NFL’s highest-paid tight end, Julius Thomas. If able to contend with what promises to be fairly relentless double coverage, the former Bronco could be the making of Bortles.
Thomas might not find life so easy in Jacksonville
There is a steep drop from the top two teams in this division to the bottom two – but at least the basement dwellers are now looking upwards. For 2015, though, the Jaguars appear capable of winning no more than five games – which would at least herald an improvement on last season and, given Tennessee’s travails, a probable third-placed finish.
Divisional ranking: 3rd
Tennessee Titans
Where else to start than with Marcus Mariota? Whether or not you agree with how Tennessee chose to spend their number-two overall draft pick, the quarterback at least brings some excitement to the blandest of NFL franchises.
There’s no doubt that Mariota is a powerful athlete but, to be successful at the next level, he will need to show quickly that he can run a complex offense and be disciplined enough to remain in the pocket.
Super Mariota has Titans fans excited
His supporting cast is difficult to judge – not least 6’5” rookie wide receiver Dorial Green-Beckham, who has all the makings of a boom-or-bust acquisition. But it’s hard not to love the second-round pick based on talent alone – if Green-Beckham irons out his disciplinary issues, Tennessee could have a franchise player on their hands for years to come.
Among Mariota’s other passing targets, Kendall Wright is talented and consistent and should be used regularly in the slot next season, with the more imposing Green-Beckham and Justin Hunter on the outside posing deep threats.
Protecting the new quarterback is an obvious priority, but the Titans’ offensive line was ghastly in 2014 and, though efforts have been made to fortify it via free agency and the draft, the depth chart does not inspire much confidence. Brian Schwenke had a poor campaign but looks set to return as starting center; guards Chance Warmack and Andy Levitre showed promise in the run game but failed to provide adequate protection on passing plays; and the tackles who started last season have both left – Michael Roos retiring and Michael Oher shipped off to the Panthers after a dreadful set of performances. They will most likely be replaced at left and right tackle by Byron Bell, who arrives in the opposite direction from Carolina after a disappointing 2014, and Taylor Lewan, Tennessee’s brightest lineman for the six games he played before injury ruled him out of the rest.
A competent running game can also help Mariota bed in – sadly, this is another area where the Titans fall short. Bishop Sankey led the ground attack in 2014 with just 569 yards, averaging a meagre 3.8 per attempt. He didn’t break off a run longer than 22 yards and scored only two touchdowns. Ken Whisenhunt has a reputation for nurturing pocket-passers, but it will be interesting to see if he lets his rookie signal-caller off the leash now and again to revive the running game.
Mariota has high end speed and incredible agility to match
One of the NFL’s most toothless offenses in 2014, the Titans will be counting on Hall of Fame coach Dick LeBeau to keep their opponents’ score down following his arrival in the off-season. As well as star lineman Jurrell Casey, the 77-year-old will have at his disposal new signings Perrish Cox and Brian Orakpo – who represent upgrades at cornerback and linebacker. The question is how much they can improve a defense that ranked 27th in the NFL last year.
Tennessee might win more than two games next season – but not much more. They are a long, long way from competing at the business end of the AFC South –but, with the signing of Mariota and Green-Beckham, the Titans have at least provided their fans with players to get behind and a semblance of hope for the future.
Divisional ranking: 4th
By Dylan Baker (@DylanBaker1986)



