Bill Belichick vs Pete Carroll

Ships in the Night

January 3rd, 2000:

The story of Bill Belichick and Pete Carroll, and how their careers will be forever linked.

Bill Belichick’s New England Patriots are preparing to do battle with Pete Carroll’s Seattle Seahawks in Super Bowl XLIX, the showcase match up – the pinnacle of the sport. ‘Big Balls Pete’s’ Seahawks are the NFL’s defending champions, and the team to beat, having won last year’s title in emphatic fashion. Belichick’s franchise is considered the dynasty of the 2000s, having won three Super Bowls and a enjoyed a seemingly ever-present playoff record ever since ‘The Hooded One’ took over in Foxboro.

Pete Carroll vs Bill BelichickPete Carroll and Bill Belichick will pits their wits against one another in Super Bowl XLIX

It may be surprising to learn that success wasn’t always a given for these two head coaches. At a time when neither looked likely to prosper in the NFL, one pivotal moment changed both their careers forever; one hugely important day, in the early days of the new millennium…

Jets, Patriots, Patriots, Jets.

Pete Carroll’s first head coaching job in the NFL didn’t last long. Carroll had been an assistant coach in college and subsequently the NFL for a combined 16 years before he finally got his shot. However, he was fired after just one season in charge of the New York Jets. His second crack at the top job, taking charge of the New England Patriots in the early days of Robert Kraft’s ownership, would be his chance for redemption. In replacing hall of fame coach Bill Parcells in 1997, he had a lot to live up to. Parcells’ Patriots had lost the Super Bowl the previous year to the Green Bay Packers. Nevertheless, Carroll was confident that he could capture the footballing Holy Grail.

Bill Belichick in disguise?Pete’s Bill Belichick disguise fooled nobody

Just weeks before Carroll began his tenure in Massachusetts, Bill Belichick was announced as the interim head coach for the New York Jets. Ironically, an interim head coach was only necessary because the Jets and the Patriots had to negotiate compensation to release Parcells from his contract with the Patriots. Once the dust had settled, Parcells was named head coach of the Jets and Belichick became assistant head coach, as well as defensive coordinator. Belichick was keen to be the man in charge, however. A second shot at head coaching, after an unsuccessful stint with the Cleveland Browns from 1991-1995, was what he craved.

Bill Belichick in his Browns attireBill Belichick – fashion icon

Millennium Madness – January 3rd 2000.

Pete Carroll’s stint at the top was short lived. He lasted just three seasons in New England before he was fired. In those three seasons he compiled a 33-30 record and made it to the postseason twice. Not exactly disastrous. Even so, Kraft was a man in a hurry and had seen enough. On January 3rd, 2000 he relieved Carroll of his duties.

Bill Belichick here we come!Patriot Pete didn’t last long in Foxboro

Several NFL teams approached him with defensive coordinator positions, but Carroll instead spent the 2000 season as a consultant for pro and college teams, doing charitable work for the NFL, and writing a column about pro football. It appeared his time as a head coach in the NFL was over. He spent the next nine years as head coach of college team USC, (The University of Southern California) a place that many believed suited his style of coaching better. Carroll’s dismissal in New England, however, left the path clear for another head coach…

When Bill Parcells stepped down as head coach of the New York Jets at the tail end of the 1999 season, he had already arranged with team management to have Bill Belichick succeed him. It was announced on January 3rd, 2000 that once again, Belichick was to be the head coach of the Jets. This time it would last for just one day. When Belichick was introduced as head coach to the media—the day after his hiring was publicised—he turned it into a surprise-resignation announcement. Before taking the podium, he had scrawled a resignation note on a sheet of paper that read, in its entirety:

“I resign as HC of the NYJ.”

Bill Belichick, young and full of hopeBill Belichick explaining himself – now a familiar scene

Belichick then delivered a half-hour speech explaining his surprise resignation to the assembled press. Not long afterwards, Belichick was introduced as the new head coach of the Patriots and the reasons for his sudden change of heart in New Jersey appeared much clearer. Upon firing Pete Carroll, the Patriots had pursued Belichick. The two coaches had passed each other like ships in the night. The league commissioner, at that time Paul Tagliabue, decided that as Belichick was still under contract with the Jets, compensation must be paid. The Patriots had to send the Jets a first round draft pick. In retrospect it was a small price to pay. Belichick has since driven the Patriots to an era of unprecedented success. After his first year, which ended with a disappointing 5-11 record, (without Tom Brady under center, it must be noted) Belichick has never endured another losing season. He has won six AFC championships and is tantalisingly close to a fourth Super Bowl victory with the Patriots.

Bill Belichick - Number 1Bill Belichick is number one in John Harbaugh’s opinion.

“He’s been a great mentor, a great friend. I have the utmost respect for him. Bill Belichick is the greatest coach of our generation, without question. I don’t think anybody would doubt that. Nothing is going to change that” – John Harbaugh, head coach of the Baltimore Ravens.

And what of Pete Carroll? After winning one National Championship with USC and leading them to seven consecutive top four finishes, he departed under a cloud of NCAA sanctions. This did not put off the Seattle Seahawks, however. In January of 2010 he was announced as head coach, a full 11 years since he last coached in the NFL. It seemed to be a gamble. Particularly as Carroll was given full control of the organisation, performing the role of general manager as well as that of head coach. Only the Philadelphia Eagles’ Chip Kelly and a certain Bill Belichick enjoy similar autonomy at the head of their franchise. The gamble has paid off handsomely though, as Carroll has missed out on the playoffs just once, securing the franchise’s first Lombardi Trophy along the way. A second crown beckons.

Look out Bill Belichick, Pete is coming for youLook out Bill Belichick, ‘Big Balls Pete’ is coming for you

Bill Belichick and Pete Carroll’s careers are clearly, inextricably linked. When they next face each other from across the gridiron, in pursuit of another Lombardi Trophy, it will be the culmination of many years hard work, on both coaches parts. But none of it would have been possible had it not been for the unusual turn of events that crazy day in January.

Whether it is the Patriots or the Seahawks that come out on top when all is said and done, spare a thought for the New York Jets. Belichick and Carroll could easily have been coaching in green and white on Sunday. As it is, arguably the best two coaches in the NFL today managed to slip through their grasp. The Jets haven’t been to the Super Bowl in 46 years.

By Robin Held (@RobinHeldNFL)

Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone.

He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk

Tags: , , , , , , ,
cammy

Coronating Cam

Some very good judges raised their eyebrows when the Carolina Panthers made Cam Newton one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL with a five-year, $103.8m extension in June. What the 26-year-old has done in the seven months since he signed the largest contract in franchise history has been nothing short