College Football Playoff System Rankings Nightmare!
The College Football Playoffs are coming! In the words of Dan Wetzel, “Death to the BCS”. After 15 years of the old, computerised Bowl Championship Series (BCS) system, college football will see the introduction of a brand new four team playoff. Junaid Hussain gives you his take on the hottest topic in NCAA sports. Is it a good thing for the sport? And who deserves to make it into the top four of the final rankings?
So, let’s start with a quick rundown of the new rules: A specially created ‘playoff committee’ will now decide who the top four teams in the country are. The committee consists of 12 members, who will create a weekly set of rankings from week ten onwards. The most important date to mark on your schedule is December the 7th, this is when the final college football rankings are published and the ‘semi-finals’ (The Rose Bowl and The Sugar Bowl) will be set.
The College Football Playoff Selection Committee: Who knew Condoleezza Rice was such a big gridiron fan?
It was only a matter of time before we got a college football playoff system because, lets face it, all the biggest decisions that are made come down to money. In the offseason ESPN signed a 12 year, $5.64 billion deal from 2014 through 2025, working out at roughly $475 million per year, to cover the college football playoffs. Many initially complained that the new system would negatively affect the student athlete, or that the regular season would cease to matter. But in reality, quite the opposite has happened.
We are already close to the finish line, with two regular season games remaining for the majority of teams, plus conference titles to decide. Before the season I predicted that the final four would consist of Oregon, Florida State, Alabama and Oklahoma (We’ll have to take his word for it! That or check his Twitter account @j_hussain – Ed).
The current College Football Playoff rankings are causing a stir…
What is interesting about the latest rankings is that two one-loss teams, Alabama and Oregon, are ranked ahead of Florida State. FSU are the only team from one of the power five conferences (ACC, Big 12, Big Ten, SEC and Pac-12) that are still currently undefeated. In previous years, under the computerised system, we simply would not see this happen.
Looking ahead, the current top two have a good chance to win their remaining games. Most of Alabama’s matchups look relatively straightforward: Western Carolina, Auburn and finally the SEC title game which most likely pits the Crimson Tide against Missouri (unless the Tigers lose a game in which case ‘Bama will be up against Georgia). ‘Bama look set to return to national relevance after a year out of the spotlight. Second ranked Oregon, with Heisman frontrunner Marcus Mariota at quarterback, are yet to play Colorado, Oregon State plus the winner of the UCLA/USC game for the Pac-12 title. The Ducks and Crimson Tide are odds on favourites and remain firmly in the hunt for the college football playoff.
Oregon’s Heisman trophy favourite Marcus Mariota leaves another defender in the dirt.
Fourth ranked Mississippi State face Ole Miss and Vanderbilt and are likely to remain a one loss team without a conference title championship to contest. Florida State will play Boston College, Florida and the ACC title game. All four of the current top four teams have winnable games and if they win out all four could well be in. The most vulnerable team is, of course, Mississippi State who languish in fourth with TCU, Ohio State and Baylor hot on their heels. After losing to Alabama over the weekend, things don’t look great for the Bulldogs. Some of their previously accepted signature wins have been degraded by their defeated foes, Auburn, LSU and Texas A&M all losing further contests and slipping down the rankings. It seems unlikely that Mississippi State will hold onto the fourth spot.
Mississippi State QB Dak Prescott fumbles the ball; have they missed their opportunity?
Ohio State appears to be the favourite to sneak into the final college football playoff position with two regular season games left plus the Big Ten title game. That could very well be against Wisconsin, who are currently ranked 16th but could end up being a top 12 team by the time they reach the title game. TCU and Baylor could both win out and would therefore be considered joint Big 12 champions. The biggest stigma going against these two teams is that there is no conference title game to separate them. When everyone else is playing they’ll be sitting at home sharing the honours and that could affect them. One of the biggest questions left to answer is whether Marshall, an undefeated team from outside a power five conference, can bust the bubble and get into the conversation? Strength of schedule has been the major focal point for the committee thus far and the Thundering Herd of Marshall are currently being punished for it, languishing outside the top 25 in the latest rankings despite winning all of their games this season.
A year ago only two of three teams would realistically be in the hunt for a BCS title spot by this point in the season. The new College Football Playoff system has opened up the floodgates and now there are seven or eight teams with a plausible argument for inclusion. One thing’s for sure, it will definitely come down to the final weekend, unlike in previous years where the season was over for the majority of teams and fans would begin to tune out. This year there has been a complete reversal. More fans are interested, joining in with debates and discussing the merits of any potential playoff team, TV ratings are up and every game really does matter. Perhaps the knowledge that the fates of their beloved universities are being decided by people, not machines, encourages fans to engage in the process like never before.
With the new College Football Playoff in place college administrators now know that strength of schedule truly is paramount and remaining undefeated is less of an imperative than in the past. Looking ahead at the schedule for some of college football’s biggest teams, let’s take a look at the opening weekend in 2016:
Clemson @ Auburn,
Alabama @ USC
LSU @ Wisconsin
UCLA @ Texas A&M
Notre Dame @ Texas,
Ole Miss @ Florida State
How could college football fans not be excited? The college football playoff has upped the ante and brought back excitement to the regular season. More fans and media outlets are interested and I have no doubt that in a few years time we will see an eight team playoff! Mark my words.
By Junaid Hussain


