Everything But The Ring…
Throwback Thursday – Bills @ Dolphins.
Robin Held takes a look back at two of the greatest players in the history of the league. Neither of them lifted the Lombardi Trophy. But who was the best quarterback never to win it all?
AFC East rivals the Miami Dolphins and Buffalo Bills are set for an important match-up on Thursday night, but neither franchise has tasted much success in recent years. Much of that can be attributed to the fact that both teams have had trouble finding a quarterback that they can rely on since the late 1990s. They did have tough acts to follow, however. Jim Kelly and Dan Marino were the linchpins of their teams throughout their careers and brought their sides into play-off contention year after year. Nevertheless, neither of them managed to win it all. It begs the question: who really was the best-ever player to miss out on a Super Bowl victory?
Jim Kelly vs Dan Marino
How close did they come to winning a ring?
MARINO
A rising star of the game in 1984, MVP and Offensive Player of the Year, Marino made what most people thought would be the first of many Super Bowl appearances in just his second season. It turned out to be the only time that Marino would play for the Lombardi Trophy. He ran into the San Francisco 49ers and an inspired Joe Montana, who dealt with the Miami defense on the way to the second of his four triumphs. Marino never got another chance.
KELLY
The most remarkable aspect of Kelly’s Hall of Fame career was that he didn’t lift the Lombardi Trophy – he appeared in a record four consecutive Super Bowls, losing them all. Incidentally, Miami are second on the list with three successive appearances, winning on two occasions. Kelly will always be remembered for his unfortunate Super Bowl record, but a missed last-minute field goal by Scott Norwood (wide right!) in his first appearance meant it could have been so different…
‘Kellying’: Tom Brady was not the first number 12 to find himself sat dejectedly on the field during a Super Bowl.
What did they mean to their franchises?
MARINO
Marino was arguably the face of the NFL, let alone the Miami Dolphins. His fame was such that he even appeared in several Hollywood movies – in fact, the plot of Jim Carrey’s Ace Ventura: Pet Detective was based on him. Marino also consulted on Any Given Sunday, allowing his house to be used as the star quarterback’s home. But it was on the field that he defined his franchise. Throughout his incredible 17-season career, Marino broke record upon record in Miami. He led his team to the play-offs ten times and Marino’s Dolphins were forever mentioned as Super Bowl contenders with the big man from Pittsburgh under center. With his strong arm and quick release proving a constant touchdown threat against any defense, Marino was selected for nine Pro Bowls. How have the Dolphins fared since his retirement in 2000? Well, they have been to the postseason just three times in 14 years, never making it past the divisional round, and no Miami quarterback has been to the Pro Bowl – despite the club trying 17 different starters under center. Miami miss Marino.
A rivalry with Jim Kelly on the field; a performance with Jim Carrey on the screen.
KELLY
Before the 1983 NFL Draft, Kelly’s agent asked whether there were any teams he would not play for. Kelly, who disliked cold weather, listed the Minnesota Vikings, Green Bay Packers and Buffalo Bills. Buffalo selected him 14th overall – “you got to be kidding me” was his response. In an act of defiance, Kelly chose to sign for the Houston Gamblers, a USFL team who played in the climate-controlled Houston Astrodome. He won MVP honours there before the breakaway league started to lose momentum. Kelly finally, and seemingly reluctantly, joined the Bills (who had retained his NFL rights) in 1986 after the USFL folded. ‘Machine-Gun Kelly’ went on to become a five-time Pro Bowler and an early exponent of the no-huddle offense in Buffalo. He used it to lead a consistently dominant Bills attack that was a scoring powerhouse, taking them to eight play-off appearances in 11 seasons. Kelly was victorious in nine play-off games as quarterback for a franchise that had only ever won one postseason match-up in the Super Bowl era before he arrived. What happened to this rejuvenated team that played in four consecutive Super Bowls? Since Kelly, they haven’t won a single play-off game, appearing only twice in the postseason in 18 years. Their play-off drought has now reached 14 years – the longest active streak in the league – and shows no signs of abating. Buffalo, like Miami, have seen a revolving-door policy at quarterback in order to fill the hole their star player left, employing 15 different starters. They are still searching for a solution to the Kelly conundrum.
Kelly took a gamble on the USFL
What do the numbers say?
There is not much to choose between the two, statistically speaking. Marino’s record-breaking longevity allowed him to rack up huge numbers of yards and touchdowns but, beyond that, there is an amazing similarity between the two quarterbacks and their career stats…
| Jim Kelly | Dan Marino | |
| Games played | 160 | 240 |
| Record (%) | 101–59 (.631) | 147–93 (.613) |
| Passing yards | 35,467 | 61,361 |
| Completion percentage | 60.1 | 59.4 |
| TD-INT (ratio) | 237-175 (1.35) | 420-252 (1.67) |
| Passer rating | 84.4 | 86.4 |
Gunslinging quarterbacks whose delivery and stats match up.
Head-to-head
The biggest difference in their career numbers, however, is in the most important stat of all: the win column. Dan Marino lost play-off games in 1990, 1992 and 1995 to Kelly’s Bills, never beating him in postseason play. Including regular-season games, Marino won only seven of his match-ups with Kelly, losing 14 to his bitter divisional rival.
In truth, it is next to impossible to separate Kelly and Marino. Both players defined their franchises. Not only for their consistently high-level play for their respective organisations, but also for their inability to get their teams over the line in the game that mattered most. Nevertheless, one thing is for sure – both of the teams playing this Thursday could do with finding their next Jim Kelly or Dan Marino.
Bonded by their on-field rivalry, Kelly and Marino remain friends to this day.
By Robin Held
Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone. He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk








