Free Agent Frenzy

Free Agent Frenzy

Where should the most valuable free agents end up?

Alongside next month’s draft, the start of free agency is the best opportunity for NFL franchises to improve their rosters before the new season. Many teams will overpay for players who will be remembered in years to come as expensive failures (Albert Haynesworth, anyone?), but others may just be able to locate the missing piece of the puzzle – that one star who turns an also-ran into a contender, or a contender into a Super Bowl champion.

Free Agent Bust Albert HaynesworthMake hay while the sun shines

For free agents, the question of where to go is usually a choice between a big payday at a less competitive team or a smaller contract with a franchise who can set their sights far higher. Is it all about the money, or should the most in-demand players look at the bigger picture? Here are some thoughts on our top five free agents, and where we think they will end up.

 

Ndamukong Suh

Opinions vary as to how deserving Suh is of the gargantuan contracts he will undoubtedly be offered by multiple NFL franchises, but there can be no debate that the Detroit Lions’ 300lb defensive tackle is the single-biggest difference-maker on the open market. Although dogged by controversy throughout his career thus far, Suh is arguably the most talented defensive player to hit free agency since Deion Sanders signed for the San Francisco 49ers 20 years ago.

The 28-year-old has been quoted as saying that his agent will decide where he plays football next season; the implication being wherever he can make the most money. And, although the Lions were unwilling to spend the $26 million it would have cost to franchise Suh for next season, there will be no shortage of rivals lining up to make him the highest-paid defensive player in history.

Suh is the top free agent availableSigning Suh will cost an arm and a leg

There is certainly an argument that a dominant, impact player such as Suh would be better off signing a less financially rewarding short-term contract with a team more likely to be immediate Super Bowl challengers, as we saw last year with Darrelle Revis in New England. But equally as enticing could be to strike a big-money deal with a franchise who are rebuilding and help turn them into a force. The Miami Dolphins fit the bill and are rumoured to be keen on Suh, but the most obvious destination is the Oakland Raiders, who have an abundance of cap room and would see him as a catalyst to reasserting themselves as a defense to be feared.

 

Julius Thomas

The Atlanta Falcons still need a replacement for Tony Gonzales and certainly have enough cap room to lure one of the league’s most productive tight ends to the Georgia Dome. Twenty-six-year-old back-to-back Pro Bowlers don’t hit the open market very often and, with his record of 24 touchdown catches over the past two years, the outgoing Denver Bronco is a rare red-zone threat. Thomas would instantly present new head coach Dan Quinn and offensive coordinator Kyle Shanahan with a formidable receiving corps led by the sublime Julio Jones. In a weak NFC South bereft of a dominant force, his addition would at a stroke turn last season’s 6-10 team into a play-off contender.

Finding a new team to play for will be easy for Thomas

Atlanta won’t have a clear path to the player, though. The Jacksonville Jaguars are expected to make a run at Thomas, who may also be a target of Oakland. Both clubs have money to burn and young quarterbacks in need of high-powered weapons. But if Thomas’ decision doesn’t rest solely on the size of his pay packet, it would be hard to argue against Atlanta as the best option.

 

DeMarco Murray

After using their franchise tag on Dez Bryant, the Dallas Cowboys effectively waved goodbye to Murray, last season’s offensive player of the year. Despite rushing for a league high 1,845 yards in 2014, the undisputed best running back in free agency has few public suitors as teams eye fresher alternatives in a deep draft class and the returning Adrian Peterson.

The most obvious landing spot for Murray, especially given their glaring need at the position, is Indianapolis. The Colts, who have not had a player rush for 100 yards in a game since 2012, cannot possibly persevere with the wretched Trent Richardson in the backfield and have the cap room to pay Murray what he feels he deserves. With an elite quarterback in Andrew Luck and an emerging crop of receivers at his disposal, the temptation to furnish an already potent offense with a proven rusher could prove irresistible. Making Murray a Colt would make the Colts legitimate AFC title contenders.

Randall Cobb

The Green Bay Packers opted not to use their franchise tag on the wide receiver, thus edging the 24-year-old closer to the open market. Oakland, who are expected to load up on pass catchers through free agency and the draft, are rumoured to be preparing an offer in the region of $10 million a year for Cobb. However, Packers fans remain hopeful that a deal can be struck to keep him at Lambeau Field, similar to how cornerback Sam Shields was re-signed shortly before the opening of free agency 12 months ago.

Randall Cobb is the top wide receiver in free agencyCobb would be a prize catch

While Cobb is unlikely to receive more at Green Bay than what is reportedly on the table – a five-year contract worth between $8 million and $9 million per season – finding a way of keeping the player in Wisconsin might be in everyone’s interests. With the imperious Aaron Rodgers playing at his peak under center, the Packers have to remain aggressive before their Super Bowl window closes. And, given head coach Mike McCarthy’s assessment that Green Bay were the best team in football when they agonisingly lost the NFC championship game to the Seattle Seahawks, parting ways with one of his quarterback’s favourite targets might prove unnecessarily disruptive.

Similarly for Cobb, this could be the one chance he gets to lift the Vince Lombardi Trophy. And, as a young, talented receiver, there are few better places to develop and perform than in Lambeau alongside Rodgers. For Cobb, the decision could be stark: stay on and try to etch your name in history, or follow in the footsteps of James Jones and Greg Jennings into prosperous anonymity. For the sake of $2 million, it might be worth both parties getting back round the table.

 

Byron Maxwell

The best free agent cornerback this season is reportedly attracting considerable interest from the New York Jets and Philadelphia Eagles. While most teams represent a step down from the Seahawks, the Eagles are relevant again under Chip Kelly but in need of an upgrade at secondary.

Aged 26 and a graduate of the “Legion of Boom”, Maxwell is perfectly positioned to demand a bumper deal – something that Seattle, looking forward to Russell Wilson’s big payday, may not be able to afford. That is not the case for Philadelphia, who have freed up resources this off-season by trading LeSean McCoy and releasing players including Trent Cole.

Maxwell himself is open to the switch, telling ESPN:

“They run the (defensive) scheme that I’m talking about. And they’re committed to winning. If they were to come at me, I would definitely have to consider them.”

By Dylan Baker (@DylanBaker1986)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,
cammy

Coronating Cam

Some very good judges raised their eyebrows when the Carolina Panthers made Cam Newton one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL with a five-year, $103.8m extension in June. What the 26-year-old has done in the seven months since he signed the largest contract in franchise history has been nothing short