Head to Head: Cornerbacks
There is certainly no shortage of dominant – and filthy rich – cornerbacks lighting up the NFL right now. Many lay claim to being the best, but which of them really is number one?
Cornerbacks are the new quarterbacks. In recent years, the cornerback position has transformed into the jewel in the crown on the defensive side of the ball, locking up lucrative contracts for its occupants in the process: Richard Sherman is signed up for $56 million with the Seattle Seahawks, Aqib Talib sealed a $57 million deal with the Denver Broncos, Joe Haden penned a $67.5 million contract with the Cleveland Browns and, of course, there is Patrick Peterson’s record-breaking extension with the Arizona Cardinals, worth a staggering $70 million.
With money flying around faster than the men who earn it, the question is: are they really worth it? And, if they are, who truly is the best cornerback in the league? Sherman, Peterson, Haden or Talib? What about Darrelle Revis? The list could go on. However, in a head-to-head, there can only be two combatants, so without further ado:
Richard Sherman – Seattle Seahawks
In the blue corner (blue, bright green and silver, actually), Junaid Hussain believes Richard Sherman is the top dog. The former fifth-round pick has been a revelation for the Seahawks and thrust himself into the public eye over the past three seasons.
Joe Haden – Cleveland Browns
And in the red corner (well, seal brown and burnt orange), Robin Held thinks otherwise. He argues the case for Joe Haden, the cornerstone of the Browns secondary, which is undergoing a remarkable transformation this season.
- Strength and tackling
SHERMAN
One of the more physical cornerbacks in the game today, Sherman is actually used against the run less frequently then you might think. The scheme that Seattle adopts also limits Sherman’s involvement in blitz packages compared with other defensive backs in the league. He is, however, primarily deployed against the opposition’s biggest, strongest and, indeed, best receivers. Sherman is an excellent tackler, which is crucial when matched up in man defense, and rarely gets beaten for big gains after the catch.
Sherman explodes towards the target
HADEN
Haden is a solid run support defender on the perimeter and does not mind being physical with his opponents. He is at his best when the ball is in the air, though, making plays with his hands and breaking up passes with his excellent timing and positional sense. In his most recent start, Haden was physical with his rival – three-time Pro Bowl selection and Cincinnati Bengal AJ Green – from the outset. On a five-yard completion towards the sideline early in the first quarter, Haden greeted Green with a huge, pounding tackle as soon as he caught it. Later in the game, a Haden tackle of Green in the open field seemed to shake the ball loose on a slant route, resulting in an incompletion. Green ended up with just 23 yards receiving on the night. He may not be the biggest, but Haden can hit when he needs to.
Haden delivers a crunching hit on AJ Green
- Coverage
SHERMAN
It’s always intriguing to see how teams plan to attack Sherman. It is rare that offensive co-ordinators choose to throw in his direction if they can help it. Sherman is often able to lock down one half of the field, shrinking the area in which the offense can operate, making teams adjust to his presence. He has been targeted more this season, though, with players including Keenan Allen of the San Diego Chargers (55 yards receiving) and Odell Beckham Jr of the New York Giants (108 yards receiving) matching up against him and having moderate success. Sherman has made 27 tackles through nine games, but has defended just four passes, forced one fumble and come down with only a single interception. This could be a sign that quarterbacks just aren’t throwing his way. Sherman has yet to be flagged for an illegal play this season, which is particularly impressive given his aggressive playing style.
Sherman gets physical one of his favourite receivers
HADEN
Haden shut down opposing teams’ premier receivers at an astonishing rate last season, holding Mike Wallace, Greg Jennings, Stevie Johnson, Calvin Johnson, Dwayne Bowe and Green to a combined total of 12 catches for 116 yards and no touchdowns in six games. Bear in mind the Browns’ paltry 4-12 record in 2013 and those figures are remarkable. If anything, Haden has been even better this year. He has made 33 tackles and defended ten passes, leading his defense to an impressive 19.1 average points allowed per game – the sixth-best mark in the league and better than Seattle’s 21.2. Cleveland have intercepted 13 passes this season (more than twice that of Seattle) and, although Haden has yet to record a pick, anyone who saw his tipped pass against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers knows how much of a playmaker he is for his team.
- Speed
SHERMAN
A former wide receiver in college at Stanford, Sherman has shown his speed in coverage, getting to the ball and making tackles incredibly quickly. He has also demonstrated the ability to stay with his man or even get ahead of him. Because of Sherman’s intelligence and experience playing both sides of the ball, he is able to read and react to the play much quicker than most cornerbacks. He may not be the league’s greatest athlete, but his smarts more than make up for it.
HADEN
Haden ran the 40-yard dash at the NFL Combine in 4.57 seconds. When compared with Champ Bailey’s 4.28 seconds, that doesn’t seem lightning-fast. However, Haden has great foot quickness, balance and agility, and maintains proper body positioning in coverage. He has excellent hip control to open, turn and run with receivers. Receivers generally have more straight-line speed than Haden; so, to adapt, he is less aggressive, often playing more conservatively and eliminating the threat of the deep pass. Nonetheless, the sight of Haden getting burnt by raw pace is a rarity – what he lacks in speed, he makes up for with positional sense.
Haden shows off his speed, amongst other things, at his Florida Gators pro-day
- Personality
SHERMAN
Sherman is the brashest of cornerbacks and loves to talk. He truly believes he is the best cornerback in the NFL – and isn’t shy about letting his opponents know.
“I’m the best corner in the game. When you try me with a sorry receiver like Crabtree, that’s the result you gonna get.”
He may come across as arrogant, and Michael Crabtree of the San Francisco 49ers won’t be sending him a Christmas card any time soon, but Sherman is able to back up his talk with his actions on the gridiron. No other player who considers himself a premier cornerback has a Super Bowl ring. Despite his bombastic and, at times, aggressive personality, Sherman hasn’t had any issues off the field. In fact, in contrast to his image on it, Sherman does a lot of work for charity, and his annual celebrity softball game drew 22,000 spectators this year.
HADEN
Life in the NFL hasn’t always been plain sailing for Haden. He didn’t start until halfway through his rookie season and was suspended for four games in 2012 for taking Adderall, which is banned under the NFL’s drug policy. Haden said that the suspension woke him up, and that getting married helped him put his priorities in order. Despite this, he still claims to be a bit on the flashy side, wearing diamond-encrusted pendants and designer sunglasses indoors. His confidence in himself is just as bold as his fashion sense, however.
“I rank myself at one. I’m going to keep grinding like I’m number one. I feel like in my heart I’m the number-one corner in the league; I’ve been feeling like that for a while.”
Not one to be outdone, Haden runs his own charity softball game as well!
- Signature performance
SHERMAN
If you study Seattle’s championship run last year, you could see just how intimidating Sherman really was. In the Seahawks’ three play-off matches, opposing teams targeted Sherman a meagre six times, and he held then Broncos receiver Eric Decker to one reception for six yards in the Super Bowl. The pattern continued early this season, when Sherman produced a quite remarkable performance. Not because of any incredible plays, but because he was barely needed! In week one against the Green Bay Packers, Sherman covered Jarrett Boykin and completely shut down one half of the field. Aaron Rodgers simply refused to throw it his way and admitted as much after the match. When head coaches and offensive co-ordinators place an emphasis on not throwing the ball in Sherman’s vicinity, they limit what they can do on offense and play into the hands of Pete Carroll and his Seahawks.
HADEN
There was a point earlier in the season when Haden openly admitted that he wasn’t playing his type of Pro Bowl-calibre football. In week eight, however, no defensive player was as prevalent and impactful as Haden. Against the Oakland Raiders, the 25-year-old led the Browns with nine tackles and added these two terrific pass break-ups:
“Those were two big-time plays he made like back-to-back in that one drive,” said head coach Mike Pettine. “The one he knocked away on the long ball I thought was special. To me, it’s a function of how he practices and how he prepares.”
In the third quarter of a closely contested 9-6 battle, Haden also added a 34-yard fumble return that set his team’s offense up near the halfway line and swung the game in favour of Cleveland. Haden has dragged his team to an impressive 6-3 record so far this season and the Oakland game was perhaps his finest.
Closing argument
SHERMAN
With Sherman’s skillset, in what is now widely considered a passing league, he must be recognised as the best cornerback in the NFL. Time and time again, Sherman has come up big in important games and he will continue to do so. Sherman’s stats may not be as impressive as they were (he led the league with eight interceptions in 2013), but all that serves to illustrate is the fear that opposing quarterbacks feel when facing him.
HADEN
Haden is the complete cornerback for a number of reasons. He has shut down some of the game’s best receivers and his all round level of play has been at Pro Bowl level for several years now. However, what makes Haden’s efforts most impressive is the fact that he has been able to stand out from the crowd in a perennially losing team. He also improves those around him, and no statistic highlights this more succinctly than the current NFL interception leader – Browns safety Tashaun Gipson. He has six already. The Browns have suffered double digits losses in every season since Haden’s arrival, a feat that, thanks to his leadership of a revamped secondary, they won’t be repeating this year.
By Junaid Hussain and Robin Held
Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone. He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk










