The Greatest Undrafted Free Agent of All Time
The Arizona Cardinals visit the St. Louis Rams on Thursday night. One man defines both franchises and their postseason successes…
The two teams in action on Thursday night – the Arizona Cardinals and the St Louis Rams – have long and storied histories in the NFL. The Cardinals were founded way back in 1898, and are the oldest continuously run professional football club in the United States. The Rams were inaugurated in 1936 and, despite their tumultuous and nomadic existence, are the only NFL team to win championships in three different cities (Cleveland, Los Angeles and St Louis). However, you don’t have to go too far back in time to find one man who means a great deal to both franchises: Kurt Warner.
“Kurt Warner, to me, could handle more under pressure than any player I’ve ever been on the field with.”
—Former Rams head coach Dick Vermeil.
The Pro Football Hall of Fame started with 113 candidates for its ‘Class of 2015’. That list has been trimmed down to 26 semi-finalists, one of whom is Warner. If Warner is indeed admitted into the Hall of Fame, he will have been selected in his first year of eligibility. Not bad for an undrafted free agent…
Kurt Warner went undrafted, then went to the very top.
Warner’s name is synonymous with both the Rams and the Cardinals, but where did he do his best work? Arizona have already inducted him into their ‘Ring of Honor’; St Louis have yet to follow suit. Thankfully for the legendary quarterback, players do not have to show allegiance to their previous employers when entering the Hall of Fame, as is the case in baseball. But, for argument’s sake, which team would Warner best represent?
Top team performance – Rams
In 1999, Warner led the Rams to their first-ever Super Bowl victory, against the Tennessee Titans at the Georgia Dome. The contest ended on a sensational play, with the Titans receiver Kevin Dyson tackled by Mike Jones just one yard short of the end zone, preventing a potential game-tying touchdown. But it was Warner who earned MVP honours – his 414 passing yards and 45 pass attempts without an interception were both Super Bowl records.
Kurt Warner with the two most valuable pieces of silverware in football.
Top team performance – Cardinals
In 2008, at the twilight of his career, Warner marshalled his unfancied Cardinals through the wild-card round, divisional round and conference championship, all the way to their maiden Super Bowl. Although they ultimately fell short against the Pittsburgh Steelers, it was a special effort from a team that finished the regular season 9-7 and lost 47-7 to the New England Patriots in week 16. The Cardinals were only the second team to finish with nine wins and reach the Super Bowl. The game itself was decided with just 35 seconds left, as Arizona had their lead cruelly snatched away from them for good by Santonio Holmes and Ben Roethlisberger. Warner still emerged with his reputation enhanced.
Santonio Holmes drags his toes to crush the Cardinals’ dreams.
“I have been fortunate to be a part of three great Super Bowls. I am definitely proud of it. Would I have liked to win more than one? Of course, but I am proud that I have been able to come to these games and be part of some of the greatest Super Bowls ever.” – Kurt Warner
Top personal performances – Rams
In his Super Bowl-winning campaign, Warner compiled what was one of the greatest seasons by a quarterback in NFL history, throwing for 4,353 yards, 41 touchdowns and a completion rate of 65.1 per cent. The Rams’ high-octane offense, masterminded by offensive co-ordinator Mike Martz, was dubbed ‘The Greatest Show on Turf’ and registered the first of three consecutive 500-point seasons – an NFL record.
Top personal performances – Cardinals
His team may have lost Super Bowl XLIII, but Warner outplayed his Steelers counterpart, Roethlisberger. Warner completed 31 of 43 passes for 377 yards and three touchdowns, with one interception. Roethlisberger connected on 21 of 30 passes for 256 yards and one touchdown, also with one interception. Warner’s passing total was the second-most in Super Bowl history behind his own record of 414 yards against the Titans (he also holds the third-best record with 365 yards in Super Bowl XXXVI).
Tools on offense – Rams
Warner’s candidacy for the 2015 Hall of Fame class was notable for another reason. The list of semi-finalists is littered with players who forged their careers in St Louis as a part of the ‘Greatest Show on Turf’. Nominated alongside Warner are offensive tackle Orlando Pace, and wide receivers Isaac Bruce and Torry Holt. They are all former Rams and were key components of Martz’s stellar offensive unit. There is no doubt that talent surrounded Warner during his time in St Louis.
Kurt Warner, Torry Holt, Isaac Bruce and Marshall Faulk – The Greatest Show on Turf.
Tools on offense – Cardinals
Warner had to fight for his starting job in Arizona. First-round draft pick and Heisman Trophy winner Matt Leinhart proved easier to replace than anticipated, however. Once Warner was firmly established as the starter, he realised he had weapons to work with. His top targets were receivers Larry Fitzgerald, Anquan Boldin and Steve Breaston. In their Super Bowl year, this triple threat lit up the league. Fitzgerald (1,431 yards, 12 touchdowns), Boldin (1,038 yards, 11 touchdowns) and Breaston (1,006 yards, three touchdowns, 904 special teams return yards) made the Cardinals the fifth team ever to feature three players with more than 1,000 receiving yards.
Anquan Boldin and Larry Fitzgerald are still playing at an elite level.
Career statistics
| St Louis Rams | Arizona Cardinals | |
| Seasons | 6 | 5 |
| Games started | 50 | 57 |
| Starting record (%) | 35-15 (.700) | 27-30 (.474) |
| Post-season record | 5-2 | 4-2 |
| Super Bowls | Won 1, lost 1 | Lost 1 |
| Passing yards | 14,447 | 15,843 |
| Completion percentage | 60.3 | 64.9 |
| TD-INT (ratio) | 102-65 (1.54) | 100-59 (1.69) |
| Passer rating | 82.8 | 91.0 |
Kurt Warner put up big numbers throughout his career (ignoring one unsuccessful jaunt with the New York Giants); both Arizona and St Louis were lucky to have him under center. He had a superior overall record with the Rams, though – winning more games and capturing that Super Bowl title. However, if anything, Warner was a better quarterback with the Cardinals. He threw for more yards, with a higher completion percentage, a better touchdown-to-interception ratio and a higher passer rating during his time in Phoenix. He just didn’t win that ring.
All things considered, it is nearly impossible to say whether Warner was more important to one franchise over another. Nobody will be surprised when he is enshrined in Canton and he remains cherished by fans of both teams alike. Perhaps it would just be easier to make him a member of the St Louis Cardinals…
A perfect compromise. Shame it’s the wrong sport.
By Robin Held
Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone. He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk



