winston

First Impressions – Marcus Mariota eclipses Jameis Winston

You work throughout your entire college career for a day on the NFL turf. You are entrusted by a team that selects you ahead of 200 of your collective peers to be the face of the franchise, the salvation from obscurity. When your day finally comes it ends in either victory or defeat, one way or another there will be a winner. That is the beauty of the NFL – the decisiveness and finality of it. No draw, no sharing of the points. There will be a winner by sudden death, shootout or overtime.  You win or lose no matter what. You work your way through college for that day in the sun. A day to remember.

jameis winstonIt was a perfect (158.3!) debut for Mariota

The top two selections in the NFL draft, Jameis Winston and Marcus Mariota could not have had two more contrasting days. The only time they played each other in college was in last year’s College Football Playoff semi-final at the Rose Bowl, when Mariota’s Oregon Ducks hammered Winston’s Florida State Seminoles 59-20. It was Winston’s only college loss in 27 starts. Now Mariota has handed Winston his only NFL loss, as his Tennessee Titans were victorious 42-14 on the road in Tampa Bay.

Mariota connected on a 52-yard touchdown in his first series to Kendall Wright. It would be his first of four touchdowns in his highly impressive NFL debut.

jamies winstonMariota looked sharp in his debut, have the Titans finally found their man?

Mariota looked composed and assured in the pocket. He had good protection from his offensive line and head coach Ken Whisenhunt played to his strengths – playing with a quick tempo, with packages similar to his days in Oregon and allowing him a quick release at the line of scrimmage, to those in the slot. This enabled receivers like Wright (who racked up 101 yards from just four receptions) to gain yards after the catch running through the gaps between the linebackers and safeties. Mariota only threw the ball 16 times. This was good management, reigning in expectations from a frenzied crowd. Do not force him to throw the ball too much; limit the potential for mistakes. That said, on a day when Mariota mostly threw laser-guided darts, mistakes didn’t seem likely.

Unanswered questions remain about Mariota once he feels pressure and is pushed outside of the pocket, he is yet to show off his running skills or an ability to improvise once a play breaks down. However, bearing in mind next week opponents are the Cleveland Browns, he should be able to maintain momentum against a sorry team that lost 31-10 on the road to the New York Jets.

jameis winstonIt was a baptism of fire for Winston

As for ‘Famous Jameis’, he might not be famous for much longer, but that would be a cruel analysis after only one game. The Titans’ Cody Sensabaugh intercepted his first pass in the NFL, returning it 26 yards for a pick-6. At 7-0 down it was the sort of play that hands all the momentum to the opposition, making it almost impossible for the Bucs to wrestle it back. The Titans built up a 21-0 lead in the first quarter and never looked back, eventually winning 42-14. Winston turning the ball over killed the Buccaneers chances.

Jameis famously won a lot of games in his second year at Florida State from positions of adversity and deficit, but the first pass was all on him, as he misread his receiver’s route and the cornerback Sensabaugh came in underneath to make the play. As for his second interception, by Deiontrez Mount, again Winston was at fault for a shallow pass that did not get over the linebacker. It was a chastening welcome to the NFL.

jameis winstonAre the Buccaneers all at sea with Winston under center?

In truth, Winston could only do so much damage to his team’s chances. They were looking slim before he even took his first snap. The Tampa defense allowed Mariota to rule the roost on his debut leaving Winston with too much to do as they played catch up all day.

There is hope for Tampa Bay and Winston as they travel to New Orleans this week. While both teams are in transition, the Saints showed little signs of a defensive improvement in their loss on the road to the Arizona Cardinals; Carson Palmer scorched their secondary for three touchdowns and 307 yards in the air. Winston probably has a better receiving corps to work with, Mike Evans and Vincent Jackson being the stand out performers, so they will remain hopeful as they face a division rival, albeit on the road. Plus, in Austin Sefarian-Jenkins he has already found a reliable endzone target to aim for, the towering tight end finished with two touchdowns and 110 yards from five receptions.

jameis winstonSeferian-Jenkins gave Winston his first two NFL touchdowns

On first impression, Mariota appears to be a calm presence at the line, in control of his emotions and making good decisions in the pocket. This was emphasised by his touchdown pass to Delanie Walker, fired into a tight window between three Buccaneers defenders. Winston meanwhile seemed a bit riled by the occasion. He was not necessarily overawed, but his decision-making was poor and he initially showed a lack of mobility to escape the pocket, which meant he couldn’t show off the athleticism he is renowned for.

Despite the obvious mismatch in their debut performances, it is still too early to call it a mistake to draft Winston first ahead of Mariota. That would certainly be a knee-jerk reaction after one game, or even after one quarter as many on social media did on Sunday. The jury is still out, but Mariota’s opening statement was a strong one.

By Jamie Garwood (@JamieGarwood)

Tags: , , , , ,
cammy

Coronating Cam

Some very good judges raised their eyebrows when the Carolina Panthers made Cam Newton one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL with a five-year, $103.8m extension in June. What the 26-year-old has done in the seven months since he signed the largest contract in franchise history has been nothing short