NFL Midseason Awards
“I don’t really care about some midseason, midterm grades. Give me whatever you want. I don’t care. What difference does it make? Give me an F. Give me a C-plus. It doesn’t matter.” – New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick
Bill Belichick couldn’t care less, but at The Neutral Zone we think now is the perfect time to stop, sit back and reflect on what has been a marvellous nine weeks of NFL action. If the recently introduced Super Bowl curtain raiser – the ‘NFL Honors’ evening – was held tomorrow, who would make their way to the podium to collect one of the coveted individual gongs? We break down who has made a stellar start to the 2015 season and highlight some of the front-runners.
The Neutral Zone’s NFL Midseason Awards
Most Valuable Player
The award for the NFL’s most valuable player is perhaps poorly titled. Essentially the MVP trophy goes to the league’s best quarterback, no matter how amazing your season may have been (I’m looking at you, J.J. Watt). No defensive player has won MVP honours since Lawrence Taylor in 1986. In fact, since 2006 every MVP has been a QB, excluding Adrian Peterson‘s magnificent effort in 2012 where he fell just nine yards short of the all-time rushing record and deservedly broke up the party.
So which QB is on course to win it this year? It is nearly impossible to look past Patriots’ superstar Tom Brady. At the halfway mark the defending Super Bowl champions remain at the top of the pile, undefeated at 8-0. Brady, who is apparently drinking from the fountain of youth this season, has thrown passes for 2,709 yards with 22 touchdowns and just two interceptions at a passer rating of 113.5. This might be his best year yet. Frightening.
It is by no means a one horse race, however. Cam Newton and his Carolina Panthers are also unbeaten, and ‘Super Cam’ is undoubtedly one of the biggest reasons. The fifth-year signal caller has been shorn of his favourite target in consecutive seasons; first Steve Smith Sr. left for Baltimore, then Kelvin Benjamin left on crutches. Despite having no real offensive weapons, (when your starting wide receivers are Ted Ginn Jr. and Philly Brown you know you have a thin depth chart) Cam has managed to keep his offense rolling, rushing for five TDs and throwing for 14. However, his nine interceptions and two fumbles lost put him behind Brady for now.
Newton certainly isn’t standing on the shoulders of giants
Honourable Mention: Andy Dalton – The Cincinnati Bengals are still unbeaten! If they manage to reach a perfect 16-0 the MVP has to be the ‘Red Rifle’.
Offensive Player of the Year
Antonio Brown and Julio Jones are having sensational seasons. In fact, some would argue that they could be in the conversation for MVP. A wide receiver has never won MVP honours, however, and there have been some pretty good ones throughout history. The offensive player of the year award is definitely within reach though.
Brown has caught 69 passes for 1,002 yards and three TDs, averaging a ridiculous 14.5 yards per reception. He set the Steelers’ franchise record for receiving yards in a single-game against the Oakland Raiders last week, with a staggering 284. It was the ninth-most of all time. Brown’s achievements are all the more spectacular considering he has had Michael Vick and Landry Jones throwing passes his way in four of the Steelers’ nine games so far.
Atlanta Falcons receiver Jones has produced equally mind-boggling numbers so far. He has already caught 80 passes for 1,029 yards with six touchdowns. Jones could break Calvin Johnson’s single season yardage record of 1,964 if he keeps chewing up ground at such a phenomenal pace.
Honourable Mention: Rob Gronkowski – The ‘Gronk’ simply cannot be stopped. In 2015 he has scored seven TDs and accounted for 693 yards. Gronkowski looks set to shatter every tight end record in the book by the time he is done.
Defensive Player of the Year
The unbeaten Carolina Panthers boast a fearsome defensive unit. The heart of that defense is linebacker Luke Kuechly. Despite missing some time with a concussion (the man is a hard hitter!) Kuechly still has 55 tackles on the season, with a sack and an interception to boot. What cannot be seen in the stat lines is his leadership and sheer competitiveness.
Kuechly has already cemented himself as one of the league’s fiercest linebackers in just his fourth season. Kuechly’s stable mate Josh Norman is also having a fine season. The fourth-year cornerback has picked off four passes, returning two of them for touchdowns, and has forced opposing QBs to look elsewhere when facing the Panthers.
The Denver Broncos’ defense has been equally stingy in the first half of the year and any one of their defensive stars could be considered for the award. Their pass rush has been a constant threat, with DeMarcus Ware and Vonn Miller wreaking havoc on the line, while cornerback Aqib Talib has been making play after play, leading the Broncos’ secondary. Talib, however, has not been leading by example when it comes to discipline. His eye poke was dangerous and petty and a one-game ban was certainly justified.
An eye for an eye and the world will be blind
Honourable Mention: Charles Woodson. Old-man-river has been a revelation in Oakland this year – leading the league with five interceptions at the ripe old age of 39. Heroic.
Offensive Rookie of the Year
Todd Gurley and Amari Cooper are a cut above the rest when it comes to the 2015 draft class. Gurley has been breaking records since he took to the field, accounting for over 100 total yards from scrimmage in every single game he has started at running back. Gurley isn’t just the best rookie running back on show, right now he is playing like the best back in the league full stop.
Gurley is already an elite back in the NFL
Cooper has made the transition from Alabama to Oakland a seamless one. He continues to catch passes and make incredible plays in the open field and has been a nightmare for even the most seasoned cornerbacks. His 653 receiving yards put him out in front of any other rookie receivers and having already built a solid relationship with young QB Derek Carr, expect AC/DC to continue tearing it up for some time.
Honourable Mention: Willie Snead. Under-the-radar for most of the year, Snead has quietly worked his way to the top of Drew Brees’ hit-list. Snead went undrafted in 2014 and had to wait until 2015 play his first down in the NFL. 626 yards and three TDs later, Snead is making sure he grabs his opportunity with both hands.
Defensive Rookie of the Year
The Kansas City Chiefs have had a tumultuous and inconsistent start to their 2015 campaign. One constant they have been able to rely on has been the play of rookie cornerback Marcus Peters. Peters has intercepted three passes (one a pick-six), made 38 tackles and defended 11 passes. A fantastic start to a promising career for the man who was once kicked out of the University of Washington.
The play of Ronald Darby has been equally important to Rex Ryan and his Buffalo Bills. A second-round pick out of Florida State, Darby has two interceptions, 18 passes defended and an impressive 47 tackles so far this year. If Buffalo manage to sneak into the playoffs, Darby’s impressive play at the cornerback position will have had a huge part to play.
Honourable Mention: Leonard Williams. A man-mountain at defensive end, Williams plays in a less eye-catching position than the two cornerbacks mentioned above. Nevertheless, he has been an important part of one of the league’s best defensive units.
By Robin Held (@RobinHeldNFL or @The_NeutralZone)
Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone.
He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk









