The Cleveland Show
Hope in the factory of sadness.
Cleveland Browns fans haven’t had much to crow about for, well, 50 years. But the steely resolve their team have shown so far this season under new coach Mike Pettine suggests that all this might just be about to change.
The Cleveland Browns could find themselves on the brink of a renaissance. Under rookie head coach Mike Pettine Jr, they have compiled a 7-4 start to the season and are suddenly relevant again. Cleveland has waited longer than any other city with at least three major sports franchises to win a title. The last time a professional sports team from Cleveland did so was in 1964 when the Browns won the NFL Championship (in the pre-Super Bowl era).
The Cleveland Indians last won the World Series in 1948 (the second-longest drought in Major League Baseball, after the Chicago Cubs) and the Cleveland Cavaliers, led by basketball legend LeBron James, have never won an NBA crown. The city even had a short-lived NHL team called the Barons, which – you guessed it – never won a championship either. In 2004, ESPN named Cleveland the most tortured sports city in America. So, you might say it was about time the Browns got their act together, for the sake of their people.
1994 was the last time the Browns won a play-off game, under the stewardship of Bill Belichick (you might have heard of his body of work at a certain ball club in New England).
A rare sighting of Bill Belichick sporting sleeves.
Cleveland finished second in their division that year, behind the Pittsburgh Steelers in the old AFC Central, but went on to beat Belichick’s current team, the New England Patriots, in the wild-card round. The Steelers, however, returned to haunt the Browns in the divisional play-offs, winning 29-9. The ’94 Browns – a who’s who of big-name coaches – also had Alabama’s evil genius Nick Saban calling plays as defensive co-ordinator.
The Browns controversially moved to Baltimore after the 1995 season and owner Art Modell decided against taking Belichick with him – unceremoniously firing his head coach exactly a week after the relocation was announced to the public.
Since leaving Ohio, Belichick has won 18 play-off games, 12 division titles and three Super Bowls, whereas sorry Cleveland have lurched from one disappointing season to another.
The Browns rejoined the NFL in 1999 and hired Chris Palmer as head coach. If they had drafted quarterback Donovan McNabb with the number-one pick instead of Tim Couch – one of the most famous busts in NFL draft history – surely they would have started the millennium in fine fettle.
Since their return to the league, the Browns have had a plethora of head coaches – none of whom managing to make any sort of meaningful impact.
Cleveland’s solitary play-off appearance since that 1994 season was way back in 2002. Butch Davis was in charge as the Browns narrowly lost a wild-card game to – yes, you guessed it – the Pittsburgh Steelers and they haven’t been back since.
Romeo Crennel, a Belichick acolyte at New England, hung around for longer than most – from 2005 to 2008. But his win percentage of .375 wasn’t much better than that of the men who followed him. Eric Mangini, Pat Shurmur and Rob Chudzinski all proceeded to stink the joint out until Pettine was handed the reins at the beginning of this year.
This year’s AFC North is proving ultra-competitive, with all four teams having banked seven wins to date. Coach Pettine looks up to the challenge and has shown a steely resolve to be his own man. Weaker first-year coaches may have bowed to pressure and blooded rookie quarterback Johnny Manziel. America has an unhealthy fascination with the former Texas A&M signal-caller. ‘Johnny Football’ is undeniably box-office and would certainly put bums on seats, but Pettine is as convinced now as he was in training camp that journeyman Brian Hoyer is his man. The former New England, Pittsburgh and Arizona backup has struggled this season, but did repay some of his coach’s faith on Sunday by engineering a last-gasp game-winning drive at Atlanta.
The Browns, starting on their own 20-yard line, only had 44 seconds to play with – but Hoyer connected with three different receivers to set up a go-ahead field goal. Much-maligned kicker Billy Cundiff drilled it home from 37 yards to secure the type of come-from-behind win that can shape a season and sometimes launch a Super Bowl run.
Pettine is certainly standing by his quarterback:
“I think the guys realise we wouldn’t be where we are right now without Brian and that nobody is perfect,” he said.
“When you see a guy who’s that hard on himself and is that much of a perfectionist, it means a lot, and they are going to play for him.”
Despite continued calls for Hoyer to lose his starting job, Manziel might have to explore his options elsewhere in the spring if he wants to forge an NFL career.
Cleveland’s play-off hopes have been seriously boosted by the return of their ultra-talented wide receiver Josh Gordon. Gordon, who served a ten-game suspension for violating the league’s substance-abuse policy, is the offensive game-changer and deep threat the Browns have craved. Their star wideout made up for lost time in his season debut against the Falcons, recording 120 receiving yards from eight receptions.
Flash Gordon helped Pettine’s boys come from behind to win a nail biter.
Pettine has also shown a willingness to trust youth. He surprisingly cut running back Ben Tate earlier this month and left his ground game in the hands of two rookies, Terrance West and Isaiah Crowell. Crowell responded to the extra responsibility and his coach’s trust by rushing for 88 yards and two touchdowns in Atlanta last week.
Like Belichick, Pettine was brought up in a coaching house. His father, Mike Pettine Sr, was one of high-school football’s most successful and celebrated minds. His Central Bucks High School West team had a 326-42-4 record in 33 seasons, winning four AAAA Pennsylvania State Championships along the way. Pettine Jr cut his teeth as a coaching assistant on his dad’s team before landing his own high-school gig as head coach of rival North Penn.
Pettine vs. Pettine on the high school football field. Pettine won.
The astonishing battle between father and son during the 1999 season was documented by an ESPN film crew in the superb documentary The Last Game. It is compulsive viewing, especially now, knowing where Pettine Jr’s career path has taken him.
Pettine Jr’s road to Cleveland has included stops in Baltimore, New York and Buffalo. A highly respected defensive co-ordinator, he was responsible for the Jets’ number-one 2009 defense. That solidity has been brought to ‘The Forest City’. The Browns’ mean defense, and their emerging secondary in particular, is a force to be reckoned with. Joe Haden is one of football’s most talented corners and safety Tashaun Gipson leads the league with six interceptions. The latter has unfortunately been ruled out for the season with a grade three MCL injury. Pettine will be disappointed but not flustered. He isn’t the sort of man that is likely to panic. Cleveland will hope they can replace Gipson’s production in the secondary.
Who let the Dawgs out? Pettine’s Browns are finally looking like contenders.
Whisper it in Cleveland but the ‘Dawg Pound’, arguably the most partisan and passionate seating section in all of football, might have something to finally get their teeth into this year.
By Sean Held



