Saints or Sinners?
Where were you at 8.47pm (GMT) on Monday 10 March? OK, so I gather by your blank expression that you’re not a New Orleans Saints fan. Then let me put it another way. What were you doing when Jimmy Graham got traded?
No-one saw coming the blockbuster move that triggered an extraordinary start to free agency – a frantic five minutes even by Jack Bauer’s standards. For the Seattle Seahawks’ 12s, the acquisition came close to matching the Jermaine Kearse juggling act for shock value – but, ultimately, this was just one more stud entering the stable.
The Saints sent their stud to the Seahawks
For the ‘Who Dat Nation’, on the other hand, it was a truly momentous moment. One of the Saints’ two blue-chip players – and the only one with his best years ahead – was being gift-wrapped for the team most likely to block their passage to a future Super Bowl. And all for a center and the penultimate first-round pick in the forthcoming draft.
It left some wondering whether patriarch Tom Benson was the only member of the Saints brass needing their mental faculties evaluated and others asking, with all the incredulity of Boston Red Sox owner John W Henry: what are they smoking at 5800 Airline Drive?
But, remarkably, that was just the start of it. The breathless talking heads were soon reporting that head coach Sean Payton and general manager Mickey Loomis were no less than “shopping the whole roster”. When Kenny Stills became the latest member of the black and gold to be bombed out of Nola, the rumours that then began to circulate on social media of the talismanic Drew Brees being next on the chopping block were almost believable. After all, if cheap, young playmakers were being purged, then why not expensive, old ones? In light of unfolding events, Brees suiting up in Jets green all of a sudden didn’t seem so preposterous.
Brees practises the New York Jets postgame pose
Payton had spoken of ringing the changes after a bitterly disappointing 7-9 season, but this was bordering on desecration – as if coach and GM, struck down by fetid gumbo, were channelling the spirits of Burke and Hare. But at least where Payton’s Irish forebears were concerned, there was method to their madness. This, on the other hand, resembled a rash, ham-fisted reboot that would make even wheeler-dealer-in-chief, Chip Kelly, blush.
New Orleans, remember, were a team whose offensive opulence put them in the conversation for Super Bowl XLIX spoils. Yet, after a campaign lost in the clutch (a pair of overtime defeats and two more games surrendered at the death), the Saints’ touchdown and pass-receiving (not to mention tackling) leaders were bafflingly deemed surplus to requirements. And so a roster short of game-changers last season goes into the next one with fewer still.
The Saints’ 2014 tackling leader, Curtis Lofton, slaps hands on his way out of town
It was a tacit admission that what Payton had built was buckling atop uneven foundations and, with costs spiralling out of control (the salary cap finally biting), the time to swing the wrecking ball and start over through the draft had come. But he of all people should know that the NFL recruitment drive is a crapshoot (having recruited his fair share of crap over the years) so when the dice do roll kindly, as they did with Graham and Stills, you don’t just give away your winnings – even when Plenty O’Toole promises plenty in return. Unless you’re Sean Payton, that is: a coach so sure of his abilities that he is willing to bet on them over those of his players – men who were tipped for greatness just a year ago. For not achieving it – or even escaping one of the worst divisions in recent NFL history – the buck stops with him. Payton ought to recognise that the Bill Belichick/Tom Brady model is not easily imitated – sure, great coaching helps, but even the best chess players won’t win when their key piece has only pawns for support.
Or…
Maybe, just maybe, Payton and Loomis haven’t taken leave of their senses – or helped themselves to Josh Gordon’s swag bag. Allow, if you will, for the possibility that they happen to know more about what is going on in their facility than those of us looking in. If the fourth estate were held to the same lofty standards as those on whom its members sermonise, many a job would have been lost following Trent Richardson’s trade to the Indianapolis Colts.
Even if Graham isn’t the unbearable braggart he appeared during protracted contract negotiations a year ago, he might well be a player still nursing a shoulder injury suffered in October 2014. It plainly aggravated him after his return from rehabilitation, leading to a drop-off from the production expected of someone earning on average $10 million per annum. Perhaps the damage is irreparable.
Graham’s shoulder limited his effectiveness in his final season with the Saints
But assuming he does make a full recovery, let’s not overlook what the Saints’ front office negotiated in return for a tight end who doesn’t block and who teams began to figure out last year.
In the words of new team-mate Michael Bennett, Graham is “soft” and “overrated”.
Payton has long coveted an elite center – and, in Oregon alum Max Unger, he now has one of the best in the business. Sure, the 29-year-old lineman won’t set pulses racing in the same way that Graham did – in fact, his work in the trenches will probably go unnoticed by casual observers. But Unger’s role – and this is the essence of Payton’s vision – will be as Brees’ new wingman, to once more make him the star of the show.
With the Super Bowl window closing, Payton recognises the importance of playing to his ageing quarterback’s strengths. And, in an offense that had become imbalanced and predictable, that means doing more than furnishing him with a towering, sure-handed receiver.
Could Unger be the Saints’ saviour?
Making Graham the kingpin of the Saints offense was a double-edged sword: one certainly capable of scything down the opposition, but equally prone to delivering self-inflicted wounds. Diverting salary from an area of necessity (the offensive line) to one of luxury (tight end) was beginning to backfire. Brees’ sack totals for the past two seasons have been the highest of his career. This combined with an increase in five interceptions from 2013 to 2014 (as Brees, under duress, indiscriminately locked in on his 6’7” target) is further evidence not, as some have speculated, of a deteriorating quarterback but of diminishing protection.
With fortifications yielding more time in the pocket and assistance for the backs, Brees’ efficacy will improve instantly. In this offense, the quarterback won’t need to unduly expose his 36-year-old arm by heat-seeking Graham or going deep to Stills. Instead, power running and controlled passing will be the order of the day.
CJ Spiller and Mark Ingram will provide Brees with a power run game
A more balanced scheme will make heroes of Mark Ingram, CJ Spiller and Brandin Cooks. Expect Payton to replace the big splash plays with a death-by-a-thousand-cuts offense, chipping away at yardage in a manner perfected by the New England Patriots on their Super Bowl-winning run (well, who better to emulate than Belichick and Brady?). More screen passes, more gadget plays, more dink and dunk. In short, unpredictability will return to the Saints offense – making Brees an altogether more fearsome proposition.
Gifted extra time after the snap, Brees can make any competent receiver smell of roses in his plug-and-play offense. In the absence of Stills – a fifth-round draft pick whose value was inflated by the Saints’ receiver-friendly scheme – any one of Joe Morgan, Brandon Coleman, Nick Toon, Seantavius Jones or whoever else joins the roster (Payton has five of the top 80 draft picks at his disposal) will prove equally adept alongside Marques Colston.
Payton searches for a solution
Make no mistake, everything that has gone down in New Orleans this post-season was born of football, not finances. Sure, it’s ballsy – but what else do you expect from a man who got the second half of a Super Bowl under way with an onside kick? According to the Gospel of Sean, the meek shall inherit squat. When your reward for finishing second is the last-but-one pick in the draft and a bunch of unhappy memories, if you’re not built to win, you’re not doing it right.
So…
Brash or bold? You decide. (Or just wait for the season to start and see for yourself…)
By Sami Shah


