Saints on the Precipice
After a gut-wrenching 7-9 season, Sean Payton spent the summer reconfiguring his New Orleans Saints around its 36-year-old linchpin, Drew Brees. Having identified the quarterback’s eventual successor, Garrett Grayson, it seemed that Payton’s immediate goal was to preserve Brees’ arm by emphasising the running game (signing CJ Spiller, offloading Jimmy Graham and Kenny Stills) and save his hide by rebuilding the offensive line (adding Max Unger, drafting Andrus Peat).
So far… so bad. The Saints’ season was over barely after it had begun. Three defeats from their first three games – including a sixth straight home loss – put the unbeaten Atlanta Falcons and Carolina Panthers out of sight in the NFC South… in September. The question now, even after last weekend’s face-saving win over Dallas, is whether the malaise is transitional or terminal. Well, it all depends on the following four factors.
1. Remaining elite under center
Newsflash. By far the easiest way of being competitive in the NFL is by having an elite quarterback on the roster. And so it has been for the Saints over many (ahem) bountiful years. For the good times to roll, the recently drafted succession plan (brief synopsis: ageing incumbent remains frisky until heir apparent suckles long enough at the teat) needs to be implemented successfully. The fly in the ointment is that what once was an electric passing game now frequently struggles to power a low-voltage eco bulb. Whether that’s on Brees or those around him (and there are plenty to point the finger at) remains to be seen. One thing’s for sure: if Brees’ production continues to drop off at the same alarming rate, or he fails to shake off the effects of his recently acquired shoulder injury, then the Saints have had it.
Saints in purgatory
2. Getting better at coaching
There is also a risk of the Saints’ second-biggest asset, Payton himself, having his “elite” status revoked. The head coach’s reputation for derring-do, fostered since that onside kick at Super Bowl XLIV, is slowly being eroded. A heady mix of unimaginative and befuddling play-calls has made observers wonder quite what went on during his season-long suspension.
Remember the week-one tilt in Arizona? The Saints, trailing by five, faced fourth down on their seven-yard line with less than two minutes to go. But instead of turning to his clutch QB and rolling the dice, Payton inexplicably called for his punt team. Suffice to say, it didn’t end well. If you’re reading this, Sean: cut out the hubris, follow the example of Packers coach Mike McCarthy and bequeath the playbook to your offensive co-ordinator, Pete Carmichael. And, when you’ve done that, perhaps use your free time to run the rule over the less able members of your support staff.
The patron saint of befuddling play calling
It seems that long-lasting relationships, rather than coaching acumen and the ability to develop players, is the main reason why certain incumbents are festering in their post. Not so the defensive co-ordinator Rob Ryan, whose likely successor, rather strangely, is already lurking ominously in the locker room. You could almost forgive Dennis Allen for smirking behind his play card every time an opposition back tears the D line a new one. Meanwhile, down the road, Kyle Shanahan’s shenanigans have Falcons fans all aquiver.
3. An effective front office
The club remains stranded in the seventh circle of salary-cap hell and, as long as it remains mortgaged up to the hilt with the Bank of Brees, no amount of clever wheeling and dealing will keep the flames at bay. But, between them, Payton and GM Mickey Loomis have made a bad situation worse. Splurging on Graham before trading him, splurging on Junior Galette before cutting him and splurging on Jairus Byrd before laying him to rest on the slab have left an unbalanced team rich with talent in some areas and threadbare in others. Well, that and a chequered history – to put it kindly – in the draft.
An ‘F’ seems appropriate in hindsight…
After trading away Akiem Hicks to the New England Patriots at the turn of the month, not one player from the Class of 2012 remains on the roster. That’s some indictment. However, the appointment of former Dolphins GM Jeff Ireland to the front office following the departures of director of player personnel Ryan Pace and college scouting director Rick Reiprish has coincided with what just might be the Saints’ best draft in years. For the team to remain competitive while in hock to Brees, it needs to keep hitting on draft picks and hope Loomis can continue finding diamonds in rough.
4. The new regime
There is no doubt that the few seasoned Saints in this unacquainted squad will have to shoulder extra responsibility this season. However, the future of the franchise lies in the hands of those yet to know their way from Bourbon Street to the Superdome. Even defensive end Cameron Jordan, 26, was made to feel old when Hicks, his junior by one year, was ousted in part to accommodate rookies such as Bobby Richardson and Tyeler Davison.
“If we go through the defensive line, we have six, seven young guys – rookies,” Jordan said. “Honestly, the organisation must feel pretty strongly about them.”
The organisation certainly feels strongly about Jordan, tying him to a bumper five-year contract extension in June. But he’s in desperate need of a wingman to replace the erstwhile Galette – with whom he combined for 14.5 sacks in 2013. Since then, Ryan’s D has gone from the sublime to the ridiculous.
But both Ryan and Jordan might have found a friend in edge-rusher Hau’oli Kikaha, who became the first Saints rookie since 2004 to record three sacks in three consecutive games after upending Brandon Weeden on Sunday. Add into the equation the heat-seeking first-year linebacker Stephone Anthony and you have, if not quite Dome Patrol 2.0, then at least a trio able to put the willies back up visiting quarterbacks.
Other pivotal position groups infused with new blood include arguably the most important – the O line – on which Unger, the bait in the Graham trade, and Peat, the Saints’ opening pick in this year’s draft, will help determine how Brees ends his career and possibly how Grayson starts his. The receiving corps is even more unrecognisable following the departure of Graham and the gifted athlete that once inhabited the body of Marques Colston.
Even Hail Marys aren’t saving the fallen Saints
It was once assumed that Brees could turn any league-minimum bum into a ball-magnet; with just a handful of starts between them, Brandin Cooks (last seen on the side of a milk carton near you) and the undrafted duo Willie Snead and Brandon Coleman will put that theory the test. Perhaps they’ll go on to become the second-greatest show on turf. That’s the thing with these Saints. At the moment, you just can’t tell.
By Sami Shah



