Untitled21

Tom Brady: A Love/Hate Relationship

Tom Terrific or ‘Bradying’? Where do you stand (or sit)?

Tom Brady is a sportsman who divides opinion. He is loved, hated and everything in between. But what is it that makes NFL fans’ relationship with number 12 so unique?

Love – Just win, baby!

There are plenty of reasons to be a Tom Brady fan, particularly if you support the New England Patriots. Brady has led his franchise to a period of unprecedented success. He was under center as they captured their first three Lombardi Trophies and has appeared in the Super Bowl twice more since. Remarkably, in a league that enforces a fair draft system and salary cap, New England have qualified for the play-offs in 11 of the 12 seasons in which Brady has started more than one game. They won their division in each of those seasons, an NFL record. Brady also holds the NFL record for play-off wins, with 18. In short, he embodies modern Pats football – winning.

Hate – Overrated?

If you happen to live outside one of the six small north-eastern states that make up Patriot country, your opinions on Tom Brady might be a little different. Yes, he won three rings but, more recently, the much-maligned younger Manning brother – Eli, of the New York Giants – has twice bested him in the Super Bowl. Critics would also point to the dominating Bill Belichick defense that was the main factor in his championship wins, the clutch kicking of Adam Vinatieri and the frankly absurd ‘Snow Bowl’ victory against Oakland, where the ‘tuck rule’ was immortalized. Brady was lucky. Right place, right time. And as much as it would pain New England’s bitterest rivals, the New York Jets (as well as fans of Buffalo and Miami), to say it, the AFC East is weak.

Tom Brady about to tuck!

Tucking lucky: Tom Brady had the ‘tuck rule’ to thank for one of his Super Bowl wins.

Love – GOAT?

Tom Brady does more than just win football games for his team. He has individually been playing at an elite level for more than a decade. He is a two-time league MVP, two-time Super Bowl MVP, nine-time Pro Bowler and holder of multiple NFL records. Add those three championship rings and you start to understand why Brady is considered one of the greatest of all time. Particularly as he has achieved these feats with a bare-bones receiving corps across multiple seasons. (Yes, Brady had Randy Moss and Wes Welker in 2007, but then he did throw for an NFL record 50 touchdowns that year!) This might prove to be his best year in that regard, working with a shaky offensive line and a misfit band of receivers: Julian Edelman (originally a punt returner), Brandon LaFell (a third-round pick acquired from Carolina), Danny Amendola (an undrafted, injury-prone slot receiver from St Louis) and Aaron Dobson (a second-year wideout with a penchant for dropping the ball).

Hate – GOAT or just a goat?

The Peyton Manning debate will always rage on. The flip side of the coin suggests that Brady is behind Manning in most statistical categories, if not the one that really matters – Super Bowl rings. Manning has been named the league MVP five times, has been to 13 Pro Bowls, holds the NFL record for touchdown passes and is less than 5,000 yards from holding the all-time passing yards record too. Tom Brady has a better head-to-head record, though – winning 11 of their 16 match-ups. However, ten of those fixtures took place in Brady’s backyard in Foxborough. Of course, Brady also has the advantage over Manning when it comes to Super Bowl triumphs. But if that is the tiebreaker in crowning the greatest quarterback of all time, Terry Bradshaw and Joe Montana are the top dogs with four rings apiece.

Tom Brady or Peyton Manning?

Competitive? Me?

“I wouldn’t change anything that I’ve ever done. I certainly wouldn’t change my career with anybody. I’ve had the opportunity to play in five Super Bowls… for one organization.” Brady has a sly dig at Peyton Manning when asked about his rival’s TD record. He also mentioned playing outdoors as opposed to playing indoors, as Manning did for 13 years in Indianapolis.

Love – Number 199

The story of the 199th pick in the 2000 NFL Draft is well-known, but that doesn’t stop it from adding to Tom Brady’s legend. Brady was selected after six other quarterbacks (The Brady 6, a film about those six unfortunate footnotes, is an ESPN documentary worth watching) and a Hall of Fame career couldn’t have looked less likely. Nevertheless, Brady rose through the ranks at New England and proved all the doubters wrong – becoming the Patriots’ best-ever player and, from the inauspicious beginnings of the sixth round, their greatest-ever draft pick. A true underdog story.

Hate – More luck than judgment

Adrian Klemm, JR Redmond, Greg Randall, Dave Stachelski, Jeff Marriott and Antwan Harris. Not exactly household names. These were the six players the Patriots themselves selected ahead of Brady. What is often forgotten in the fairytale story of Brady’s draft is that his beloved Coach Belichick passed on him just as often as the other 30 teams in the league. Judging by the photo of Brady at the Combine, you can see perhaps why…

Tom Brady looking, let's be honest, scrawny.

 Tom Brady the Adonis

Love – The geek who inherited the earth

From his humble, almost embarrassing beginnings at the Combine and the 2000 NFL Draft, Tom Brady has gone on to reach the pinnacle of the sport. But he has also won the game of life. Brady is married to a stunning supermodel in Gisele Bündchen, has multimillion-dollar homes in Los Angeles, New York and Boston, is friends with the Hollywood elite, has appeared in numerous ‘sexiest man alive’ lists and even made a cameo in The Simpsons. All this for a man who still can’t get a high-five on the sideline from his teammates.

Hate – The green-eyed monster

Tom Brady was mad. Bro.

‘U mad bro?’ Number 12 does indeed look mad.

Even though Seattle cornerback Richard Sherman loves to trash-talk with almost everyone – just ask Michael Crabtree or Patrick Peterson – he took special pleasure in giving it to Tom Brady after the Seahawks beat the Patriots 24-23 in 2012. It seems that Brady is a magnet for attention from opposing players, fans and even journalists. A lot of the criticism he receives is probably down to sheer jealousy. Who wouldn’t want Brady on their team? Who wouldn’t want to be Tom Terrific? OK, perhaps that is overkill, but the fact is that nobody hates a player who is irrelevant. Brady’s overt celebrity status and supermodel wife don’t help his cause when it comes to being a man of the people, though…

Love or Hate, the end result is the same.

What will the game miss when Tom Brady retires? Everything. Brady has said that he will only call it quits when he “sucks”. It is hard to imagine a world in which Brady sucks – perhaps his unusually poor week-four performance against Kansas City gave his critics the briefest of glimpses. His detractors’ gloating was short-lived, however: Brady’s form since that mauling at Arrowhead has been nothing short of sensational and he won the AFC Offensive Player of the Month award for October. Brady led the Patriots to a 4-0 record that month and completed 100 of 144 passes for 1,268 yards with 14 touchdowns, no interceptions and a quarterback rating of 129.1. It has always been unwise to write off this ultra-competitive veteran.

One thing is for sure, when the 37-year-old does retire, the game will be shorn of one of its biggest and most polarising stars. Patriots fans will miss their best-ever player, their leader and their hero. And those on the other side of the fence will miss having somebody so easy to root against, somebody so easy to get fired up to play against and somebody who makes that rare victory against the Patriots even more special. People love to hate but, when number 12 does choose to hang up his retro bobble hat and call time on a Hall of Fame career, the only thing left to feel will be respect.

Tom Brady will look back on a stellar career.

Looking back on a glittering career, however, is not Brady’s mindset. He wants another ring before he retires.

By Robin Held

Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone. He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk

Tags: , , ,
cammy

Coronating Cam

Some very good judges raised their eyebrows when the Carolina Panthers made Cam Newton one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL with a five-year, $103.8m extension in June. What the 26-year-old has done in the seven months since he signed the largest contract in franchise history has been nothing short