Washington and New York – A Historic Rivalry
Washington and the New York Giants have a rivalry that stretches back over 80 years, to their first game in 1932. The Giants lost to the Boston Braves, 14-6 in their first meeting (Washington would later inherit the franchise). The two teams have squared off a total of 166 times, with the Giants leading the series 97-65-4. On Thursday night the two renew the rivalry as they battle to get their seasons on track.
Throwback Thursday
Washington @ Giants
The rivalry has been mostly marginalised in recent times and because of this, the majority of younger fans will not understand the passion that older fans have when discussing the games. The rivalry was best defined in its earliest years, when Washington and the Giants faced off against each other on the last game of the year for several seasons in row.
On December 5th 1937, the two sides faced each other in a vital regular season game. A win or a tie would send the Giants to the NFL championship game to play the Chicago Bears. Washington had other plans however, and with the support of 12,000 fans and a marching band that owner George Preston Marshall brought to the game, they routed the favoured Giants 49-14. Washington advanced to face the Bears and defeated them 28-21 to become NFL champions for the first time. The Giants got their revenge the following year by defeating their rivals 36-0, progressing to the championship game and beating the Green Bay Packers 23-17.
Washington back Cliff Battles scores against the New York Giants in 1937
Washington and the Giants would have several close games over the course of the next 30 years with both teams winning NFL championships – Washington in 1942 and the Giants in 1957. However the next most prominent game was on November 22, 1966.
The two sides faced each other in what was to most outsiders an unimportant game. But any contest between these two great rivals was never unimportant, especially during an era when both teams were considered to be mediocre at best and any division win, particularly against a rival, was treasured. The game was an offensive blitzkrieg. Pro Football Hall of Fame quarterback Sonny Jorgensen threw three touchdowns whilst under center for Washington as they steam-rolled the Giants 72-41.
The game remains the single highest scoring profession contest in NFL history with a total of 113 points scored. The final three were scored on a last second field goal that was seemingly unnecessary, but which Washington head coach Otto Graham maintained he called for to give his kicker Charlie Gogolak ‘practice’. Gogolak scored 14 extra points that day, still an NFL record. As this game was played before the installation of nets behind the goal posts, a large number of footballs were lost to the stands and not retrieved. The total of balls lost was reported as being 14. 13 through field goals or extra points and one thrown into the stands by Washington safety Brig Owens, who managed to score two defensive touchdowns during the contest.
Washington receiver AD Whitfield catches the first of his three touchdowns
The rivalry peaked most recently during the 1980s. During this period the two teams were powerhouses in the NFL, combining for 10 playoff appearances, 5 division titles, 4 conference championships & 4 Super Bowl appearances, winning 3 (Washington: 1982 & 1987, New York: 1986).
In 1982 Washington was one game away from clinching a playoff spot. The 1982 season was notable as it was considerably shorted due to player strikes. Each team only played nine games. Washington went into the locker room at half time against the Giants down 14-3. In the second half they leaned on kicker Mark Moseley to win the game for them. After clawing back to 14-12, Moseley drilled a 42-yard field goal (which was tipped by Giants linebacker Byron Hunt) through the uprights to give his team a 15-14 victory. Washington continued the run and won the first of their three Super Bowls under coach Joe Gibbs.
In an unprecedented turn of events that is almost definitely not to be repeated; Mark Moseley was voted as league MVP; the only kicker to have ever been awarded this honour.
“I think once I got nominated it was such an unusual thing that everybody voted for me. When they called me to tell me I had won it, I was shocked beyond words”.
In 1985, Washington and the Giants faced off in a Monday Night Football game that would be cemented in NFL history. It was a game that both ended the career of a Super Bowl winning quarterback and made Lawrence Taylor one of the most feared linebackers to have ever played the game.
Washington came into the game 5-5 and were looking to move above .500. In the second quarter of the game, with the score 7-7, quarterback Joe Theismann took the snap and ran a flea flicker play. Lawrence Taylor was not fooled, however and drove into Theismann for the sack. Taylor was joined on the sack by several other Giants players. Once the bodies had been cleared, Taylor frantically screamed for a paramedic. Theismann’s leg was bent at a 45 degree angle; his tibia and fibula had snapped clean in half. Theismann never played football again and even now walks with a limp.
Not for the faint of heart…
The sack by Taylor, now known as “The Hit That No One Who Saw It Can Ever Forget” has been regarded as the direct reason that left tackle is now such a highly paid position in the NFL, as they protect the (right handed) quarterback’s blind side.
In 1987, the sides met again in the NFC championship game. The Giants, under Bill Parcells, put on a master class, holding their opponents to a total of 190 yards on offense and not allowing them to score a single point. The Giants would win 17-0 and go on to win their first Super Bowl title.
Parcells led his team to glory
The rivalry between Washington and the Giants cooled during the 90’s and into the new millennium, with fans seemingly less interested by the match-ups between the sides. But on the field the rivalry burned as hot as ever. Following their second Super Bowl win in 1990, the Giants headed into the 1991 season feeling very confident. However, they started the season in uninspiring fashion, sitting at 4-5 heading into the game against Washington, who were 7-0.
The Giants played well in the first half under new Head Coach Ray Handley, going into the locker room up 13-0. It was not to last however as Washington took control in the second half and scored 17 unanswered points to take the victory. Washington would advance all way to the Super Bowl and win their third title in nine years. The Giants would finish 8-8.
In 1997, the old foes played in what was most probably their most disappointing and uninteresting game since the NFL-AFL merger. The contest would finish a lacklustre 7-7 with the teams combining for 22 punts. It was memorable, however, for the antics of Washington quarterback Gus Frerotte; after scoring a second quarter touchdown to tie the game, Frerotte slammed the top of his head against the wall. It was later revealed that this caused Frerotte to have strained his neck. It has become a point of comedic relief for Washington fans ever since.
Gus Frerotte needs a head examination
The rivalry between Washington and the Giants has not been much of a focal point in recent years. But as can be seen by their history, it is as varied and colourful as any in the NFL, with many games being cemented in NFL lore. It is surely only a matter of time before another match-up rekindles memories of times gone by. With the Giants struggling at 0-2 and Washington seemingly heading in the right direction for a change, perhaps tonight’s meeting will be it…
By Tony Wenham (@Tony_Fett)





