Rookie Wide Receivers beware!

Beware the Sophomore Slump

‘Manners maketh the man’; a mantra some men in the NFL forget after a few weeks in the big leagues. The rookie wide receiver class of 2014 certainly have every right to feel too big for their cleats. Odell Beckham Jr. of the New York Giants exploded onto the scene with that catch and then straight into the referees’ bad books with a string of fines, unsportsmanlike behaviour and even a brawl. The monstrous ‘Megatron’-esque 6’ 5” Kelvin Benjamin suggested he tanked his 40-yard dash at the NFL Combine so he could be selected by the Carolina Panthers and hook up with Cam Newton – hardly the most gentlemanly of actions.

Wide Receiver Kelvin Benjamin runs the 40 yard dashWide Receiver Kelvin Benjamin runs a ’40’ that Rich Eisen would be proud of

Maybe these rookies are simply making their mark, like so many professional footballers do, in a league where sportsmen are hardly paragons of virtue. They would do well to remember the likes of Terrell Owens, Eddie Royal and Harry Douglas’ second year blues, and more recently, Cordarrelle Patterson’s disastrous second bite of the cherry. Perhaps the more appropriate maxim for this rookie wide receiver corps should be ‘beware the sophomore slump’.

Wide Receiver Cordarrelle Patterson found life difficult second time aroundCordarrelle Patterson experienced a huge drop in production in his second season

Only 11 rookies have ever amassed over 1,000 receiving yards in their debut season and three of those were in 2014. That in itself is a staggering statistic, but when you factor in the fact that Odell Beckham Jr. missed the first four games of the year with a hamstring injury, it becomes even more remarkable. The National Football League saw Beckham Jr. (1,305 yards), the Tampa Bay Buccaneers’ Mike Evans (1,051), and Kelvin Benjamin (1,008) all break the 1,000 yard barrier, while Sammy Watkins of the Buffalo Bills came close with 982 yards.

Receiving Yards – Rookies, 2014 – A record breaking bunch.

1. Odell Beckham Jr. WR, New York Giants  1305
2. Mike Evans WR, Tampa Bay Buccaneers  1051
3. Kelvin Benjamin WR, Carolina Panthers  1010
4. Sammy Watkins WR, Buffalo Bills  977
5. Jordan Matthews WR, Philadelphia Eagles  813
6. Jarvis Landry WR, Miami Dolphins  758
7. John Brown WR, Arizona Cardinals  696
8. Allen Hurns WR, Jacksonville Jaguars  677
9. Taylor Gabriel WR, Cleveland Browns  620
10. Brandin Cooks WR, New Orleans Saints  564

From the outset it appeared to be a memorable year for rookie wide receivers. However, if you scratch a little below the surface, there are a few important things to note.

The NFL has never been so pass happy. Franchises, more than ever, are searching for that passing quarterback who can unlock defenses. The average quarterback rating in 1985, another stellar year for rookie wideouts, was 70.7. This year, where quarterbacks are more valued, more heavily utilised, and therefore pass more to their wide receivers, was 88.3; the signal callers are simply performing better.

To top this off, college football has also showed an increased perceived value in the passing game – pushing more and more NFL-ready star receivers into the big show. This season sees the likes of Amari Cooper, Kevin White, Devante Parker, Phillip Dorsett and Dorial Green-Beckham trying to make the jump. It’s likely at least one of these players will join the 1,000-yard club in their rookie season.

The 2015 Combine Wide Receiver classCooper, Dorsett and Green-Beckham wait nervously. If they think this is bad, just wait for the draft!

With their first year successfully negotiated, the next challenge for 2014’s crop of receivers is to double down and keep up the impressive start to their careers.

  1. Odell Beckham Jr. certainly made hay when the sun shone, taking advantage of Victor Cruz’s unfortunate ACL injury. But even once he’d made his mark early season in lax 1-on-1 coverage, and safeties and cornerbacks had his card marked, he was still a nightmare match-up for secondaries.

Expect to see Odell Beckham Jr. to continue wowing crowds and, barring serious injury, record another 1000+ yard season.

Wide Receiver OBJ and that catch‘So good I forgot to do my job!’ – Cameraman

  1. Physical freak Mike Evans racked up over 550 receiving yards in November alone last season. It wouldn’t be a complete disaster if the Tampa Bay star made that many yards in 2015 in total – although it’s likely he’ll be among the receiving leaders again. He hauled in 12 touchdowns last year, good for joint fourth in the entire league. He will feel he can replicate that effort this year, particularly as the Buccaneers hold the number one overall draft pick and are looking to acquire Jameis Winston to partner their star second year receiver.

Evans and his Buccaneers could be the surprise package of 2015, particularly if ‘Famous Jameis’ Winston lands in Florida. Evans could end up posting top five receiver numbers if things go his way.

  1. Kelvin Benjamin has performed admirably in his first year at Carolina under a fair amount of pressure. Pre-season, some commentators made comparisons between Kelvin and Calvin. The new Megatron he is not, but his stout stature and secure hands have hidden doubts over his route running. A lack of any other viable passing option at the Panthers, other than tight end Greg Olsen, thrust him into the number one receiver slot almost immediately and has allowed the first round pick to take advantage of the multitude of targets sent his way.

A low scoring Panthers offense could hamper his second season showing. Expect a more modest tally of reception yards in 2015, as secondaries look to nickel and protect packages to double cover the Florida State alumnus.

  1. A Buffalo Bills team in playoff contention, heading into the final three weeks of the season, had hard-working rookie Sammy Watkins to thank for many of their victories in 2014. Always willing to go the extra mile, he spent every morning of training camp studying playbooks and routes to try and eke out that extra bit of performance. Watkins fell agonisingly short of 1,000 yards first time around, which was reminiscent of his effort against the New York Jets!

Watkins’ natural ability and work ethic are likely to continue to pay dividends as the Bills plump for the newly traded for Matt Cassel to provide targets for the sophomore star. With LeSean McCoy now in at running back, play action must be respected. A 1000+ yards season is certainly attainable.

  1. Jordan Matthews has provided Chip Kelly’s Philadelphia Eagles with a significant deep threat in his signature high tempo offense. Despite setting SEC records with 262 receptions and 3,759 career yards, the Vanderbilt star still had a lot to prove. Finishing with 800+ yards and 8 touchdown receptions in his rookie season made for a promising start.

Matthews lines up behind veteran Jeremy Maclin (if he returns after free agency) and Riley Cooper in the depth chart and would be lucky to post another 800+ yard season with increased attention from the secondaries. Expect a slightly stunted sophomore season from the second year wideout.

Whether an anomaly or a vision of things to come, the wide receiver class of 2014 was certainly an impressive one. The real test will come when franchises have a chance to create plans for these wide receivers and they no longer have the advantage of being an unknown quantity. Who will continue their meteoric rise and who will fall back to earth with a bump?

By Patrick Held (@HeldontoPatrick)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,
cammy

Coronating Cam

Some very good judges raised their eyebrows when the Carolina Panthers made Cam Newton one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL with a five-year, $103.8m extension in June. What the 26-year-old has done in the seven months since he signed the largest contract in franchise history has been nothing short