Wide receivers head to head

Head to Head: Wide Receivers

Head to Head - Wide Receivers

Wide receivers are incredibly important. The Hall of Fame is littered with them. Behind the quarterback, wideouts are probably the most famous players in the NFL and certainly some of the most controversial. That isn’t to suggest that all wide receivers are divas, but for every Jerry Rice there is a Michael Irvin, for every Reggie Wayne you have your DeSean Jackson. Why do head coaches, general managers and owners put up with the wide receiver prima donna? Because they win you games.

In today’s NFL there is a plethora of wide receivers with game winning skills on show. In fact, the position appears healthier every year, with each new class of rookies seemingly adding to the outrageous talent pool in the league. But who is the cream of the crop? The man you go to on fourth and ten, with the game on the line? The player who just cannot be covered? Sean Held and Robin Held take sibling rivalry to next level and argue the case for two wide receivers that simply cannot be ignored.

Jordy Nelson is one of the best wide receivers in the NFL.Sean Held has Jordy Nelson at the top of his Christmas list.

He hasn’t been to a Pro Bowl yet, let alone been voted All-Pro. He may not be a physical freak of nature like Calvin Johnson. He may not be lightning-quick like Steve Smith. He may not have pianist’s hands like Larry Fitzgerald. But if I could trade for any wide receiver in football, I’d move heaven and earth to land the Green Bay Packers’ Jordy Nelson.

Yes, he has arguably the best quarterback in the NFL throwing to him. But Nelson makes Aaron Rodgers look great too – it isn’t a one-way street. Don’t take my word for it, Rodgers says so himself:

“Jordy makes ‘em look easy at times. It makes me look good.”

Nelson is A-Rod’s go-to guy for a reason. No duo can pull off the difficult back shoulder throw and catch as often or as successfully as Rodgers and Nelson. Nelson’s timing is unerring.

Calvin Johnson is one the best wide receivers in the NFLRobin Held thinks that if you’re talking wide receivers, you’re talking about Calvin Johnson.

Calvin Johnson is a freak. In a good way. The man known as Megatron has been tearing up the record books for several years now. He holds the NFL single season receiving yards record and is on course to shatter many more. In performing at a level that is often hard to fathom, Johnson has become the receiver that defenders fear the most. Just ask legendary cornerback Darrelle Revis:

“He’s a man amongst boys out there,” Revis told the Boston Herald this week. “You see it all the time. The dude’s 6-foot-6, 230 pounds. And he runs a 4.3 (second 40-yard dash). That’s pretty freakish.”

As Revis contemplated the concept of Megatron invading Revis Island, the New England Patriots’ veteran defensive back kept the compliments coming…

“It’s like an alternate (universe) receiver that you want,” Revis said. “So if you could create a receiver in a video game, that’s basically what he is. I have a lot of respect for him. I feel like our defense has a lot of respect for him. He has a lot of respect around the league as well.”

Megatron is certainly respected. More importantly he is feared.

1. Hands

NELSON

Nelson hangs on to the football more than most of his peers. He only dropped the ball three times in 2013 and has the concentration and toughness to make plays between the hashes as well as on the outside. Nelson did have two uncharacteristic drops against the Philadelphia Eagles in Week 11, but still finished the game with 109 yards and a touchdown. He certainly impressed Eagles cornerback Bradley Fletcher, who said of him: “He’s a total receiver.”

JOHNSON

Johnson has the ability to catch almost any ball that is thrown his way. His other worldly wingspan and intimidating height allow him to come down with passes that mere mortals would only dream of reaching. He also doesn’t make many mistakes. Johnson has dropped just 22 passes in the last three years. If you want to see an example of great hands under immense pressure, check out Johnson’s fourth down juggling act against the Miami Dolphins as he gets hit by not one, but two Dolphins’ defenders.

2. Speed

NELSON

Nelson is not the fastest guy you’ll see, but he’s big at 6’ 3” and 217 pounds. He has deceptive speed because of his long stride pattern. Nelson doesn’t beat coverage with raw speed and won’t out leap many corners. But his mental strength and football intelligence make these non-issues.

JOHNSON

For a man that is built like a skyscraper, Johnson can seriously move. He ran the 40-yard dash at the combine in 4.34 seconds. That is more than 0.2 seconds quicker than the average for his position. The 29-year-old has been able to mix his immense physicality on the field with blistering pace, a combination that is near impossible to defend against.

3. Route running

NELSON

There is not a better receiver in the NFL when it comes to beating coverage, making decisions and running smart routes. Nelson is great at analysing what is put in front of him, adjusting to the looks he’s given and making sure he finds himself wide open.

JOHNSON

It is hard to get as consistently open as Calvin Johnson does. It is even harder to do so when you are double covered for most of the game. In fact, Johnson has found himself double-teamed for a large part of his career! Nevertheless, in running his routes he continually manages to provide a window of opportunity for Matthew Stafford that defenders cannot cover.

4. Signature performance

NELSON

Jordy Nelson averaged 23.2 yards per catch against the New York Jets in September and ultimately turned the game in favour of Mike McCarthy’s men. The Packers rallied from an 18-point deficit with Nelson at the fore. He ended with 209 receiving yards and his 80-yard touchdown reception in the third quarter was the game’s decisive score.

JOHNSON

329 yards. Not a bad stat line for your team’s receiving corps on any given Sunday. That is how many yards Megatron was responsible for on his own when he tore up the Dallas defense last season. It was good for the second best effort of all time. These weren’t garbage time yards either, his team were down by ten points in the fourth quarter. The game ended 31-30 and was close the whole way, with Johnson setting up the game-winning touchdown run (a sneaky keeper by quarterback Matthew Stafford) with a huge 22-yard reception as time ticked down. Megatron could not be stopped that day, catching 14 passes and adding one touchdown grab for good measure.

Closing Argument

NELSON

The statistics this year show that Nelson is now elite. He is currently ranked third in receiving yards, with 998. Of the league’s wide receivers, only his teammate Randall Cobb, a red zone favourite of Rodgers, has more touchdowns; Cobb has ten TDs in 2014, Nelson nine. Nelson already has 60 receptions this year with his average completion going for 16.1 yards with a total of 325 yards after the catch.

Not bad for a guy who played defensive back at a Division II college in Kansas his freshman year and was a walk-on during his sophomore year at Kansas State University.

In many ways Nelson should be applauded for thriving when he hasn’t been blessed with the same attributes as many of his contemporaries. He doesn’t have a physical advantage over the defenders he faces. He isn’t quicker than the majority of them and doesn’t have jaw-dropping intangibles.

The 28-year-old just trains his backside off, runs amazing routes, makes stunning catches and scores a bucket load of touchdowns. This blue collar football player – who spends his off-seasons harvesting wheat at the family farm in Manhattan, Kansas – is now a blue chip wide receiver.

JOHNSON

The facts speak for themselves when it come to Calvin Johnson. He is the gold standard for wide receivers and has been performing at an elite level for many years. Yes, he has been laid low by injury this season, but you’d be mistaken if you thought that anything has changed. Megatron truly is a sight to behold when he is in full flow. He is box office, and every head coach in the league would salivate at the thought of him lining up on their side of the ball.

The Oakland Raiders had their chance to draft one of the greatest wide receivers of all time at the 2007 NFL Draft. They chose quarterback JaMarcus Russell first overall instead. Megatron was selected second and the Detroit Lions could not have been happier.

How important is he to the Detroit Lions? Johnson steps up when they need it most, and makes some seriously big plays. Johnson ranked third overall in the NFL for total receiving yards last season, but a lowly 16th for yards after the catch. What does that tell you? Megatron catches bombs. You wouldn’t want to throw it to anybody else with the game on the line and you’d be even more foolish to put him second on your list. Just ask the Raiders.

By Sean Held and Robin Held

Robin Held is the editor of The Neutral Zone. He can be contacted at: editor@theneutralzone.co.uk

Tags: , , , , ,
cammy

Coronating Cam

Some very good judges raised their eyebrows when the Carolina Panthers made Cam Newton one of the highest-paid quarterbacks in the NFL with a five-year, $103.8m extension in June. What the 26-year-old has done in the seven months since he signed the largest contract in franchise history has been nothing short